boarding schools (and Hillerska specifically) in fact and fiction
The results of this poll about whether or not youād want to attend Hillerska have been revolving around in my head over the past few days. I flippantly voted yes (spoiled Swedish teens feel like a piece of cake compared to reality at the moment) but in practice generally agree with many of the reasons stated in the no column. So, if you did vote no and say why, know that I agree with you. This isnāt a post to argue against you or anything, this is just an extended wondering about something else.
At the same time, I noticed that we heard a lot from the nos and not as much from the yeses in response to this poll. In complete earnest, I wish we could have heard more from the yeses. (If you did vote yes and want to message me about your ideas one on one, Iād love to hear from you and I promise I donāt bite.) Iām curious to know if some of the same things about Hillerska-as-a-setting appealed to you as did me when I first started watching the show. Because itās an engaging enough setting that I, you know, do own the Hillerska hoodie and all.
I do want to acknowledge how, in creating Hillerska, the writers drew on harrowing stories of real boarding schoolsāclass hierarchy, insular social mores, outdated traditions, secrets, horrific acts of hazing. The writers researched all of this, interviewing former students, and incorporated that into Young Royals to increase the sense of realism and play to the showās class commentary.
I also started thinking about how the show leans into boarding schools as a literary device. In youth-centered fiction, boarding schools are a kind of liminal setting that facilitates independence from adults and a higher level of agency for teenage protagonists. These teens are called to make decisions and sort out conflicts amongst themselves. Thereās this idea of, who can you become without your family looking over your shoulder? In what ways do you feel pressured to be like them, or to break away from them? And all the gothic architecture and uniforms and secrets and traditions are easy for writers to convey through a lens of romanticism.
And⦠Young Royals does not fully reject that romanticism. Indeed, it embraces it often. It uses the romantic boarding school angle to market the show and grab our attentionāfor example, see all the promo material where the characters are in their uniforms getting photographed for student picture day and such. The creative team offers us the romanticism of boarding school the same way they offer us the romanticism of intense first loves between princes and commoners.
I actually think Wilhelm and Simonās relationship and Hillerska-the-liminal-space as a setting are very much intertwined. Hillerska is a catalyst for Wilhelm and Simonās relationship; if Wilhelm fell in love with Simon in a club or on a train, and not in the school chapel where Simon is singing a solo in defiance of posh students who heckle him, their story would be completely different. I canāt (personally) imagine Wilhelm and Simonās story without the beats of school parties in the Palace, or their hugs-in-white-nightgowns on Lucia night, or their stupid grins at one another during rowing practices, or their stolen kiss at the Valentineās ball. The school provides a lot of obstacles to their relationship but it also facilitates these iconic moments of connection between the two of them, and I feel like in the first two seasons at least thatās supposed to matter.
And maybe, stick with me here, but I donāt⦠think itās like, wrong, or hypocritical or whatever, that YR leans into romanticism and realism re: Hillerska at the same time? I actually think itās pretty common in school-focused stories to put these two modes of storytelling in dialogue with one another? The romantic (in the literary sense, not the conventional) elements of a boarding school story are there to honor the tempestuous emotions of the teenage characters in their coming of age, as they bump up against adult pressures and the first hints of the ārealisticā adult world. (Iām thinking about like, Dead Poetās Society, and A Separate Peace, and A Great and Terrible Beauty as other examples of this. They all make social commentary through their setting but they also immerse you in it and sweep you up into it.)
I know Hillerska doesnāt survive the series and Wilhelm and Simonās relationship does, and Iāve heard that after season 3 there were some things said in interviews and some extremely mixed messages about the setting at times. But also like⦠look. For all the later stumbles with the writing, Iām a slut for setting and a slut for setting as a way to reveal character arcs and facilitate relationships and Hillerska is a setting that captivated me from the beginning and itās a lot of what made Young Royals what it was.
No I would not want to attend the school in real life as a real life human. Yes I would love to spend more time there in fiction because that is how fiction works, you get to explore settings you wouldnāt want to explore in real life. Go ahead and accuse me of being at the devilās sacrament because didnāt we all meet at the devilās sacrament?
Credit goes to @heliza24 for the devilās sacrament joke because sheās smarter and funnier than me.