The Online Connection (Grayson Waller x Female OC) WWE Fanfic - Chapter 40
Synposis:
WWE Superstar Olivia Parker hasn't had it easy. After a horrific car accident resulted in losing part of her right leg and a spinal fusion, her long wrestling career has been put on hold indefinitely. Fortunately, a group of good friends and lots of therapy have her on the path to creating a (somewhat) normal life.
Like so many other people, Olivia spends way too much time scrolling on TikTok. It's there that she comes across NXT Superstar Grayson Waller late one night. A split decision results in them forging an online connection that's both electric and hilarious.
As time passes, one thing becomes clear- the connection between Olivia and Grayson is undeniable. Between banter, social media posts, and late-night DMs, there's something slowly building up to be more.
But what happens when that online connection goes offline?
Content warnings: Car accident, injuries sustained in car accident, death of a loved one (from years ago), mental health struggles, past trauma, explicit sexual content (praise, body worship, masturbation)
FIRST MASTER LIST / SECOND MASTER LIST
TAG LIST: @new-zealand-chic @stephwrestler
Matt - May 2023
My first SmackDown taping turns out better than I could have hoped. I host my first The Grayson Waller Effect on the main roster without a hitch, relishing in the crowd’s booing as I interview AJ Styles. Even though I can’t wrestle due to my leg injury, the fact that I’m still making my main roster debut has me in a state of awe.
It helps that I’m able to catch up with a few old buddies from NXT before the show. I also chat with some of the wrestlers Olivia had introduced to me during Wrestlemania. Many of them welcome me to SmackDown with open arms, much to my relief. I don’t feel like the new kid in school, trying desperately to fit in. Between the guys I worked with in NXT and the established main roster WWE Superstars, I know I’m going to settle in quite well.
I receive a text from Olivia after my segment ends. I smile when I see her message appear on my phone.
Olivia: YOU DID SO GOOD OUT THERE!!! I’m so proud of you, baby!
Matt: Thank you, sweetheart. I’m happy it went well
I go to Instagram to find Olivia’s WWE Instagram has a new Story uploaded. I click on it to find a photo of SmackDown playing on her living room TV during The Grayson Waller Effect. I’m sitting at my desk, looking unimpressed as AJ is busy making his entrance.
“I’m more of an AJ Styles fan tbh” the on-screen text says.
Scowling, I do something I haven’t done in months- slide into Olivia’s DMs.
graysonwallerwwe: RUDE
olivia_wwe: lol we meet again
graysonwallerwwe: Looks like it
olivia_wwe: Well regardless, I stand by what I posted. AJ Styles > Grayson Waller
graysonwallerwwe: I’m a better wrestler than that flop!
olivia_wwe: lol whatever helps you sleep at night. I’m gonna enjoy the rest of the show now. Love you!
graysonwallerwwe: Love you too, even though you’re being mean to me
olivia_wwe: I’m definitely gonna enjoy sharing my bed with the dogs tonight
graysonwallerwwe: You do that
Chuckling, I shove my phone into the back pocket of my jeans so I can watch SmackDown on a monitor backstage.
“Who you talkin’ to?” Oscar says while taking a seat beside me. He adjusts his signature mask, which is royal blue.
“My girlfriend,” I reply.
Oscar smirks. “You two are still going strong then?”
“Yeah, we’re good,” I say. “I’ve been staying at hers since I broke my leg.”
Upon hearing this, Oscar’s smirk fades. “You’re staying at Olivia’s place?”
I freeze. “Only temporarily, ‘cause she offered after I got injured.”
“And you’ve been there ever since?”
“Yeah, pretty much. I should probably go back to my place. I’m sure the food’s all mouldy by now.”
I force a chuckle to ease my newfound nerves. But Oscar’s face remains unclear, and him wearing his mask doesn't help. I look back at the TV monitor as the hairs on the back of my neck stand up.
“When did you get injured?” he asks.
“During my last match at Spring Breakin’,” I answer, my eyes glancing at my cast before looking back at Oscar again.
“When was that?”
“Late April.”
“And you’ve been staying at Olivia’s ever since?”
“Yeah. Although, I probably should’ve offered to return home at some point. I just…haven’t. And she hasn’t said or even hinted that I should leave soon.”
Oscar relaxes, his expression curious. “Olivia’s a really generous person. I’m not surprised she would do something like that.”
“She’s amazing,” I blurt out.
My face heats up when I realize what I just said. I let out a bemused chuckle and run one hand through my short, dirty blonde hair.
Oscar’s brown eyes narrow as his smirk returns. “Oh, so this is really serious.”
I hesitate, but nod anyway. I refuse to bring up the fact that I want to marry Olivia, even though my feelings on the topic are still the same.
For a moment, no one speaks. My stare returns to the monitor again, only for me to realize that SmackDown is almost over now.
“I’ve known Olivia a long time,” Oscar pipes up, forcing me to look at him. “I met her when she was really young- sometime after she joined the main roster. She was extremely nice and generous then, and she’s still that way now. She hasn’t changed in that way despite all the fame and money.”
I don’t doubt the truth behind his words. She strikes me as someone who wouldn’t let such frivolous things turn her into a bad person.
“But I also know how much she’s been through,” Oscar continues. “I’ve seen her cry over her parents’ deaths more than once. I can’t begin to comprehend the amount of loss she’s dealt with.”
I recall the time when Olivia came over to my apartment on the anniversary of her car accident, her heart heavy with the trauma of that awful day. I can’t forget how she hugged me for dear life and wept over both it and not having her parents around to comfort her. It’s clear that she’s doing the best she can, although she still has bad days too. But I’m not about to tell Oscar any of this.
“She’s overcome a lot, and I’m proud of her,” I finally say. “I think the world of Olivia, I really do. I’m sure I sound like a lovesick idiot, but I couldn’t care less. It’s the truth.”
Oscar grins. “I’m glad she has you.”
I return his grin. “Nah, mate, I’m the lucky one.”
***
Late next morning, as I’m carpooling with Pretty Deadly back to Orlando, I send Olivia a text.
Matt: May I please ask you something?
I get a response about half an hour later.
Olivia: Sorry, I was rolling around in the ring at the PC. What’s up?
Matt: Wait, you were?? Shit, I shouldn’t have interrupted.
Olivia: You’re fine! I needed to take a break anyway.
Matt: How’s it going?
Matt: That wasn’t my question btw, but I’ll get to that
Olivia: lol no worries. It’s…an experience. There are some moves I’m struggling with because of my stupid leg. It’s just going to be a bit of a learning curve, that’s all. I’m trying to not be too hard on myself.
Matt: I understand, baby. If I could get in the ring with you, I would.
Olivia: I know, and I appreciate the thought. So…what was your question?
I bite the inside of my cheek before typing out my next message.
Matt: I know I’ve been staying at your place for quite a while, and I appreciate it. But I should probably head home. I don’t wanna put you out anymore than I have. Are you cool with me doing that?
Olivia: I mean…if you want, sure. But don’t feel like you have to
Matt: It’s okay. I want you to have your place back.
Olivia: Okay
Again, I bite the inside of my cheek. This time, it’s to keep a curse word from slipping out of my mouth.
Matt: Alright, I’ll grab my stuff once I make it to your place. I won’t be there for a few more hours
Olivia doesn’t reply; instead, she leaves a thumbs up reaction to my last text. This causes my stomach to tie itself into a knot. I put my phone away and try to chat with Pretty Deadly about the show and God knows what else.
I know this is the right thing to do. As much as I appreciate Olivia taking care of me since my injury, I can’t stay at her place forever. Even though I know she doesn’t mind having me, she deserves to have her space back.
The next few hours pass by uneventfully. It’s just after two in the afternoon when the guys drop me off outside Olivia’s home. When I realize her car is in the driveway, the knot in my stomach tightens. I half expected her to still be at the Performance Center.
I slowly hobble up the porch and enter her home. Gary’s barking echoes from the living room as he races over to greet me, his tail wagging a mile a minute. I briefly greet him before shutting the front door behind me. When I poke my head in the living room, I realize Olivia isn’t there.
Frowning, I go to the top of the basement stairs and listen closely for any noises coming from the lower level. When I don’t hear anything, I go to the glass sliding door to peek into the backyard. Yet Olivia isn’t there either.
Despite my crutches, I trudge upstairs while pain darts up my leg. I curse under my breath when I finally reach the top. Once the pain settles down, I scan my surroundings from the landing.
Out of all the doors, only one is half-open- the door to Olivia’s office.
My frown deepens. How did she not hear me come in, or hear Gary barking his head off?
I hobble over and quietly peek my head in.
Olivia is sitting at a white desk in front of a silver iMac, typing away with ease. I can see the computer screen reflecting off the lens of her glasses, though I can’t make out exactly what’s on her screen just from that. Her red hair is up haphazardly in one of her claw clips, with several strands framing her makeup-free face. She’s wearing a black The Judgement Day sweatshirt from WWE Shop that appears to be a couple of sizes too big.
I also spot the explanation for her not hearing anything- a large pair of white noise-cancelling headphones covering her ears.
I scan the small office. The walls are white, with a black shelf of action figures resting against one of the walls. It only takes a moment for me to make out that they’re WWE action figures of Olivia from over the years. Another shelf- a tall, narrow one made of glass- sits kiddy-corner on the other side. Inside are the three titles Olivia has won during her time in WWE. Her Divas Championship sits at the top, then her WWE Smackdown Women’s Championship, and finally her WWE Raw Women’s Championship. There’s a large window to my left, accented with black linen curtains. It’s not just any old home office- it’s also a makeshift time capsule of Olivia’s WWE career.
For a minute or so, I watch her write ferociously, pouring words onto her screen without a second thought. Her gaze is locked onto the task at hand with laser focus.
I look down to find Ash nearby. He’s laying on his side in a black dog bed, snoozing. Then I look back at Olivia, who continues to write.
I wave one hand in her direction, but she doesn’t see me. Then I slowly creep inside her office. It proves a little tricky with my crutches, but I manage a few steps before Olivia suddenly whips her head over at me.
I freeze the moment we make eye contact.
I’m about to try and get the hell out of there, but Olivia raises a finger to silently tell me to give her a second. I watch her go to her phone and then pull her headphones off.
“Sorry, I was looking for you,” I say. “I wanted to say hi, that’s all.”
“No, it’s okay,” Olivia replies. “Here, give me a second to close out of everything.”
I watch her focus on her computer for a couple of minutes before pushing her fuzzy white sphere-shaped office chair out from the desk. It takes her a moment to drag herself out, and she visibly winces.
“I’m still pretty sore from wrestling with my friends earlier,” she adds before I can ask if she’s okay. “I haven’t wrestled in over two years and it was only the second time I’ve gotten back in the ring since being cleared.”
“Well, I’m glad you’re okay,” I say.
Olivia saunters over with a smile on her face. On the surface, she seems alright. But I know her real smile. It stretches from ear to ear, lighting her entire body up from within. It always reaches her eyes, making them sparkle even on a dark day.
This smile is different from that. It’s smaller than normal and appears to be contained only on her face. The rest of her body seems stiff and rigid.
She’s not herself- and I know why.
“Did something happen during training?”
“No, it went fine.”
I frown. “If you’re upset about what I texted earlier-”
Olivia sighs, rendering me mute. She takes her hair down, tossing the clip on her desk.
“I’m not upset that you want to return home,” she says. “You can do whatever you want, you’re a grown-ass man. I’m just confused where this came from. You’ve been staying at mine without any issues, but now you’re suddenly worried about overstaying your welcome.”
I rake one hand through my hair and exhale slowly.
“Here, why don’t we go to the bedroom so you don’t have to stand on your broken leg?” Olivia offers, her voice softer.
I happily accept the suggestion since my leg is still sore from coming up the stairs. I follow her into the master bed and sit on the bed as soon as possible, with my leg propped up with a pillow in case it’s swelling inside its cast.
“I’m not trying to upset you,” I start.
“I’m not upset,” Olivia repeats. “Did I say or do something recently to cause this, though?”
“No,” I insist, shaking my head.
Olivia knits her eyebrows together. “Then where is this coming from all of a sudden?”
Knowing that it’s better to be truthful than to lie my way out of this, I tell her about how my conversation with Oscar yesterday made me realize how long I’ve been staying at hers since my injury. I make a point to emphasize that Oscar didn’t suggest that I head home; rather, it’s something that I thought of on the drive back home today.
“I don’t want you to think I’m trying to take advantage of your kindness or generosity because that’s not what I’m trying to do at all. I should’ve offered to head home sooner, and I’m sorry I didn’t,” I conclude.
Olivia’s eyebrows furrow deeper. “Matt, you haven’t done anything wrong. If I wanted you to leave, I would’ve asked you to. I haven’t been silently seething about you being here, wishing that you would head back to your apartment sooner than later. I love having you here, I really do. And I never had an inkling that you were taking advantage of me.”
My body sinks into the comfy bed as my stomach unties itself. I find myself hanging my head, ashamed that I had let such insecure thoughts win.
“I love having you here, I really do,” Olivia adds firmly. “If you wanna head home for a few days, that’s fine. But please don’t do it because you think I’m sick of having you around.”
I sigh and look up to see her sitting criss-cross while holding my hands. She gives them a squeeze, making me grin.
“I’ll talk to Oscar about what he said-”
“No, don’t be mad at him,” I interrupt. “He didn’t say anything like that, babe. It was just something I thought about when we were talking about it.”
Olivia nods slowly. “Alright, then. So…are you gonna stay or no? It’s totally up to you, I don’t have a preference. But like I said, please don’t leave because you think you have to.”
I mull over the options. As much as I would love to stay, a small part of me still feels like I’m overstaying my welcome. Then again, the cast on my right leg is making it impossible for me to drive anywhere. She still has to drive me places since my doctor has ordered me not to drive. While I’ve mastered showering and getting dressed on my own, there’s still that massive hurdle to throw a huge wrench into things.
“I should head home for a little while,” I say after a moment of silence passes. “I’m sure a lot of the food in my apartment has gone bad and is stinking up the bloody place. But I also can’t drive with this fucking cast on. I could have you drive me to mine…”
I trail off to debate what to do for another minute. Then I let out a heavy sigh.
“Actually, I’ve changed my mind- I’ll stay.”
Laughing,Olivia gets up on her knees and plants a tender kiss to my lips. I happily accept, pulling her in close. She soon wraps her legs around my waist with ease. I bite back a groan building in my throat.
“That works for me,” she remarks, pulling away just enough to lock eyes with me. “I have an idea- why don’t we drive to your place so I can give it a deep clean, and you can grab anything you’d like to have?”
“But you’re busy with writing,” I argue. “I feel bad that I interrupted you in the first place.”
Olivia waves this off. “I can write anytime, Matt. Besides, I’m supposed to be taking care of you, remember?”
I chuckle as Olivia traces my scruffy chin with one finger. Her light pink nail scratches my skin lightly enough for me to feel it without stinging.
“I won’t argue,” I say once she finishes touching my face. “And I’m sorry that I caused all this trouble. I should’ve just asked if you wanted me to head home or not, rather than assume.”
“Don’t even worry about it. We’re good, sweetheart,” Olivia replies.
“Good,” I remark, my grin transforming into a full-blown smile.
Our conversation ends soon after so that Olivia and I can go to my place. Thankfully, the apartment doesn’t smell, although there’s a fair amount of long-forgotten food that has to be tossed. Olivia handles that and cleaning my place from top to bottom while I grab more of my belongings. This includes clothes, toiletries, and one of my many Philadelphia Eagles hats.
It isn’t until later that evening, long after returning to Olivia’s home and having dinner, that I ask her about when she thinks she’ll be coming back to the ring. We’re sitting across from each other on the living room couch while a Friends rerun plays on TV.
“Honestly? I’m not entirely sure,” she admits, her tone cautious. “I know it’s gonna be before SummerSlam, so probably not until late July, I guess? But there’s a chance WWE could ask me to come back sooner. It’s not like I have to worry about whether or not I’m cleared.”
“Makes sense,” I say.
“I would love to come back sooner, I really would. But as far as I’m concerned, the ball is in WWE’s court.”
“No, I get it.”
Olivia suddenly grins. “I signed a new five-year contract the other day, and I know which brand I’m gonna be wrestling on when I do return.”
I immediately perk up. “Do I get to know?”
At this, Olivia smirks. “If I tell you, will you promise to keep your mouth shut and not tell a soul?”
“Absolutely,” I proclaim loudly. “You have my word.”
“So dramatic,” Olivia quips with a giggle. “I’m gonna be on SmackDown.”
My eyes widen and I cackle. “Seriously?”
Olivia nods. “I didn’t even ask to go there, I swear to fucking God! They just asked if I would be fine to wrestle there, and I said yes. It was that simple.”
I shake my head in disbelief. “Looks like we’ll be traveling on the same brand together.”
“Looks like it,” Olivia laughs. But then her laughter dies at the same time as her smile.
“Hey, I’m not that bad to travel with,” I tease. Yet even as I say it, I know that’s not the reason for her sudden change in mood.
“No, no, that’s not it,” she says, her tone mousy. “I just still haven’t told my fans about my mental health issues.”
I raise my eyebrows. “You haven’t?”
Olivia sighs heavily. “I did tell my friends after Wrestlemania. They all reacted well, which I was really relieved about. And then after that, I decided I was gonna post about it. But then I started working on my third book, and I focused on taking care of you after you broke your leg- not that I’m blaming you for this at all- and, well, I…forgot.”
I fight the bemused smirk threatening to bloom. “You forgot?”
“Okay, I lied; I didn’t forget, I just…decided not to. I kept using work and life as excuses to not do it. Sounds really stupid when I say it out loud, I know.”
“It’s not stupid.”
“But it is.”
I reach out to touch Olivia’s wrist. She pulls her hand into mine, so I give hers a gentle squeeze.
“I keep going back and forth on whether or not I should do it. You know as well as I do that wrestling fans can be vicious. I’m worried that, if I post about this, they’re gonna insult me for ‘being weak’, for a lack of a better way of putting it.”
My jaw abruptly tightens just from hearing that. How the fuck could anyone think that of Olivia everything everything she has survived? She lost her parents when she was barely an adult, and then nearly lost her own life in a car accident that robbed her of her right leg and put her wrestling career on hold. There are so many people who wouldn’t have been able to handle the mental anguish that comes from enduring such hardships. Yet here Olivia is, doing as well as she possibly can in spite of all that.
I know she’s not the same person she was before going through those hardships. Hell, I’m sure she’ll never be the person she once was prior to those tragedies occurring. But from what I’ve seen since our very first online interaction, I know she must have worked incredibly hard to get to a much better place.
“I know my friends will defend me from those pricks,” she continues, “and I know you will too. But that doesn’t mean I wanna read nasty internet comments about my mental health struggles. Honestly, just the thought of telling so many people I don’t know something so personal about me is really scary.”
I nod wordlessly.
“Then again,” Olivia says, “I know talking about my mental health online could very well help someone who has been through something similar. After all, I’ve gotten a lot of DMs from fans telling me how much my debut novel helped them on their own grief journey.”
My ears perk up upon hearing this, but I keep my mouth shut.
“Maybe the same thing will happen with this,” she adds. “Ugh, there I go rambling on and on.”
“Don’t apologize,” I pipe up, knowing that’s what she’s about to do. “I never mind hearing you talk.”
Olivia flashes a halfhearted grin. “I appreciate that. I still don’t know what I should do, though.”
I muse her words for a moment. “Do you want my opinion?”
Olivia’s grin fades as she blinks in stunned shock. “You’re asking?”
“I didn’t wanna assume that you wanted to hear it.”
“No, please.”
I squeeze her hand again. “You are right- wrestling fans can be assholes about those things. But I’d be willing to bet that anyone who responds to you revealing your mental health struggles rudely isn’t a real wrestling fan- they’re just an asshole looking to stir up trouble. And if they were a fan of yours, then they can fuck all the way off, as far as I’m concerned. They don’t get to say they’re a fan while also acting shitty towards you.”
Olivia’s face brightens up a little.
“And talking about it online could help someone, I agree with that sentiment,” I carry on. “I could definitely see that happening.”
At this, Olivia nods.
“However,” I say, “the choice is ultimately yours. If it’s something you feel comfortable with doing, then share it online. If not, then don’t. Either way, I love you and I’ll support your decision. And if you do decide to do it, I’ll defend you from any dickhead who tries to make fun of or insult you.”
“Thank you,” Olivia replies softly. “I’m overthinking the hell out of this, I know I am.”
“Only a little,” I remark. “But honestly? I think I lot of people in your shoes would.”
“Yeah, I could see that,” Olivia says.
I let go of her hand and open my arms wide. “Come here.”
Just as Olivia begins to scoot over to me, Gary suddenly hops up on the couch and jumps into my arms. His tail wags happily while Olivia bursts out laughing.
“I didn’t recall telling you to come here,” I say sternly, staring at Gary with narrow eyes.
“He can join us,” Olivia insists before closing the distance between us on the couch.
Soon enough, my arms are around her body while she pets Gary, who sits quite content in her lap. Ash joins us on the couch a moment later and takes the empty spot in between my spread out legs. He rests his head on my left knee with a sigh.
I kiss Olivia’s head. “Feeling better?”
“Much.”
“Good. Wanna watch a movie? Or did you wanna get back to writing?”
“Oh, I definitely wanna watch a movie with you! You pick.”
As we settle on the couch to watch Sleepless in Seattle, I make a point to hold Olivia a little tighter than usual. After all, there really is no other place I would rather be than with her.









