I've added an edit to the original this morning to point out that it wasn't my intention to represent Hebrew as a dead language. The intent was rather to give an extreme example relating to both living and dead languages.
I get that.Ā I even understand that.Ā And, to some extent, I even sympathize with that.Ā But, as the (incredibly appropriate in this context) saying goes, āIntent is not magic!āĀ
Now, I hate it when I make a simple mistake and people jump all over me, so Iām going to say this much: your correction?Ā A very good first step, and I applaud you for doing so.Ā The fact that you owned up to the mistake is good, instead of getting defensive, and Iām specifically going to take this point to ask my followers to not jump down your throat and make you defensive.Ā
But still, at the end of the day, you are still part of a cultural tradition that has been built by directly stealing bits of Jewish cultural heritage and shoehorning it in nearly at random.Ā This is not a thing for which I blame you, but instead a thing that I blame the system that taught you.Ā
Iāll put it this way; Iām an atheist, but, due to my RPG hobbies, I get alot of exposure to Occult topics, either via practitioners who are also in the hobby, or just from background reading for my hobby.Ā In the course of a decade of that exposure, I have just about never seen a non-Jewish occultist, of any tradition, treat Jewish cultural topics with any degree of institutional sensitivity, or, really, as anything other than a source of Generic Mystic/Arcane Symbolism.Ā Individual occultists being sensitive and understanding?Ā Yes, they do exist, and youāve shown that youāre one of the decent sort and not one of the smug ones, for which I thank you.Ā But as for the tradition as a whole?Ā Well, my opinion starts with āvastly irksomeā and quickly veers into the sort of language Iām not comfortable using when I know I have 14-yo followers.Ā And thatās my general position on Western Magick Occult traditions.Ā Some of the people in it are decent, but the tradition itself is vile to me because of centuries of abuse and theft.Ā