About toothpaste goats and gender, and why they are a-okay
Hey there! Rando from the internet speaking again.
The recent development in chapter 5 have also caused some distress in many fans for our dearly beloved Ralsei - or, more implicitly, Ralsei’s implied coming out as a transwoman (or trans woman, depending what writing you prefer), or (perhaps) non-binarity.
While other fans have been cheerful and with sparkles in their eyes, others looked at said development with sadness. Given arguments have been that they would prefer a feminine, but otherwise cis-gendered Ralsei. Maybe a bit fruity. Maybe a bit gay. For a better representation of feminine/fruity/gay men and boys in media!
I’ve voiced my opinion about this already. Ralsei is a character, not a person, within a story, written by an author, who can develop the character in whatever way it pleases him. There is no obligation for any development whatsoever for Ralsei to be written in a specific way, you can like this or not - and if you do not like the canon version, why not make up you own Fan-Ralsei to your own liking? (After all, it is not like the transwoman-adorers wouldn’t make up their own little headcanons and ships about Ralsei in other ways.)
Thing is, while this sounds all nice and logical, I still also found myself in the crowd of guys sad about a Ralsei who feels like a female with she/her pronouns - a situation which makes me pretty pissed about myself.
I am in no way against transness in the slightest - some of my best friends are trans (Disclaimer: I know what this sounds like, you don’t have to tell me, it is a joke), and I see no reason in neglecting the wish of someone who feels body-or genderdysmorphia to change their life for the better, ergo choosing the gender, names, pronouns, or body etc. that they wish to have. And yet, with Ralsei, I was saaaaad. What is going on here? Why this NIMBY-ism from my side from me when in comes to them?
In my case, like for many other people I presume, is it that I identify with Ralsei to a degree. We both like certain things attributed to femininity, we both like being friendly, heck, we both wear glasses, we like to collect – or wanting to collect – plushies, and even have an affinity for horsies (looks up to MLP plushies). And so far, we both also seemed to be male, even though the idea of transness and Ralsei had been brought up before. But, trans - I am not, no. And here the joy of overidentification begins.
This is not about loosing an icon or an ideal for myself - more feminine men or boys in the media are available like sand at the seaside. No, even though Ralsei is just a character, I have spend a lot of time thinking about them, drawing them, or even using them as a symbol in chats. Some people by this point have to *think of me* when they see Ralsei.
I noticed that some fanartists, or artists in general, tend to refer to the characters they draw as their daughters or sons. Isn’t that interesting?
People who maybe still live at home (if not most of them, lots of people in the community are teenagers or young adults) do not in the slightest wish to become a parent, but feel enough connection to a fictional character that they call them their child, and state how *proud* of them they are!
Now, if this is possible, then it is fair to assume that in my case, we can see the same effect - only that I am not happy about the way my beloved child is developing. Like many parents, or fathers with sons, I have developed a picture if my child which now is cracked, if not cracked up (See? See? Metaphor!!!).
As someone who grew up under a father who told me in the face that they “do not accept me the way I am”, without even realising the weight of these words, I certainly know that I don’t want to turn into a kind of person who is not okay with the normal development of people around them - or in this case, some odd fictional father not happy with the development of their fictional offspring.
And from a rational, logical point of view, it is quite clear how to act in this situation IMO. Accept your child for what it is. That's what a good parent does. It's not up to your. It is not *about* you.
But that’s how it is. Logic can change circumstances as fast as a light switch can be turned on and off.
Emotions? They take time. We are not built to change the way we feel about someone, or something, like simply pressing a button. We have a choice HOW we treat them - emotions are not our actions - but no matter how we do it in the end, they must find their natural course through our system, until we can accept certain things and move on.
This is also why Flowery is such a jerk in chapter 5 towards Ralsei - just because you have come to terms with things already, doesn’t mean someone else can also just do it as easily when certain emotions are connected with it (among other things - the Ralsei-Flowery dynamics are more complex, I am aware of that).
What I am trying to say is, if you see someone sad about Ralsei not just being a gay toothpaste boy now, do not just smear into their face that they should shut it and just move on. For move on they will, if not when the last 2 chapters come out and the story comes to an end.
That is, of course, if that is all that there is. As I have said before, if someone acts like Ralsei has been the cishet hero of the universe so far and the transness- aspects sucks, well. Certain people don’t want to see things, especially in the times we are living in. Or, more bluntly – if someone is acting like an… (looks up Ralsei vocabulary) unhealthy, unfriendly and unpleasant fella who is not open for positive and useful suggestions, maybe it is a better idea to move on from there, or dismiss the conversation whatsoever.
In the end, time will bring the truth and heal all wounds. And I don’t want to be a dismissive parent towards the nicest fluffiest goat I know. No matter what pronouns they will use in the end, what gender they have, be it prince, princess or both - I have trust that they will be a well-written, round character, and I will be okay with what they are.
It’s nice that Ralsei is Ralsei.










