Shenanigans and Small Closets
Benedict Bridgerton x Reader
Masterlist - Join My Taglist! - Send me a Fictober request!
Written for Fictober 2025! Requested by @auroracalisto - thank you for being so patient while I worked on this! I had a ton of fun writing this one, and I hope you like it :)
Fandom: Bridgerton
Day Twenty Prompt: "Trust me, this will work!"
Summary: Benedict's best friend since childhood has an idea for getting revenge on Anthony after he cheated in pall mall, and she's not about to let Benedict sit out the enacting of the plan.
Word Count: 2,028
Category: Fluff
Putting work into an AI program without permission is illegal. You do not have my permission. Do not do it.
"Trust me, this will work!"
I stared straight into the eyes of my best friend, Benedict Bridgerton, willing him to believe what I was saying. He raised an eyebrow, and I could see the doubt in his eyes, but to his credit he was still standing in the small hallway alcove with me.
"...I suppose I've trusted you this long. One more leap of faith isn't too much to ask, with all of that considered."
I grinned at him. "Thank you. And just think about the expression on Anthony's face when my plan goes off without a hitch!"
Benedict shook his head, but he smiled nonetheless. I smiled back, leaning my shoulder into his.
Technically, we were far too close for propriety. But we'd been joined at the hip since we were children, and we were in Aubrey Hall with no one besides his family and the staff. I wasn't about to let my best friend sit out of shenanigans because society had recently decided we weren't allowed to exist within two feet of each other.
In pall mall yesterday, Anthony had completely cheated to prevent me from winning, and I was not about to let that stand. So, I'd come up with a plan to get my revenge, via a bucket full of water balanced over a doorway I knew Anthony would be walking through shortly.
"I hope you have a plan for the moment after the water hits its mark," Benedict muttered, so close to me that I could feel his breath on my neck. I repressed a shiver, and immediately after, repressed any analysis of why I might've felt a shiver coming on.
"The plan is to hide here," I said. "Where we'll see him and he won't see us."
"And if he does see us?"
"Then I'm going to run, at least fast enough to be faster than you."
Benedict scoffed and rolled his eyes, and I responded with a grin. Before either of us could continue our conversation, however, the trapped door swung open with Anthony's typical level of force, sending the perilous bucket of water tipping over and straight onto his head.
He gasped, already scowling, as my hands shot to my face to try to stifle a laugh. Just behind me, Benedict wasn't quite as successful as I had been. A horrible, half-muffled snort escaped him, and Anthony's head whipped instantly in our direction.
All three of us froze for a moment, and then all hell broke loose.
"Run!" I shouted, whirling around and shoving Benedict ahead of me as Anthony bellowed our names, clearly having realized we were to blame.
Just ahead of me, I could see Benedict shaking his head as the two of us sprinted through the hallways of Aubrey Hall, like we had when we were kids. Despite the situation, I couldn't keep a slightly manic smile off my face.
"Come on, Ben! I know you can run faster than that!" I called, putting on just enough speed to pull ahead of Benedict. I heard him huff behind me, and I could tell he wasn't quite as amused as I was.
Of course, to be fair, his brother would probably actually punch him if he caught up to Benedict first. He'd be more likely to pick me up and drag me all the way outside to throw me in the lake in retaliation.
"We need a better plan than just running!" Benedict called, still just a half-step behind me. I hummed. He was right. Luckily for both of us, I'd practically grown up in this house, too, and I'd spent a lot of time exploring these hallways, including after Anthony had to step up and do real work instead of spending time with Benedict and I.
"Just follow me," I huffed, quickly turning a corner and then yanking Benedict after me through a door to a servant's supply cupboard. I knew Anthony had no idea it existed, and honestly, I doubted whether Benedict knew, either.
I tugged the door shut behind us, putting my back to the wall in the small, dark space with Benedict just in front of me. I wished I could pretend that my heart was only racing from the running and the adrenaline.
"What a-"
"Sh!" I hissed, putting a finger to my lips to silence Benedict as quickly as possible. We stood so close to fit both of us in the closet that my finger wasn't far from touching his lips, too.
A moment later, we heard Anthony's footsteps go thundering past outside. Neither of us so much as breathed, staying absolutely still and listening as carefully as we could. Mercifully, it sounded like Anthony had gone right past us without a second thought.
I met Benedict's eyes, huffing a quiet laugh as a small smile of relief pulled onto my face.
"I think we're in the clear," I said, still smiling, although I wasn't totally sure why anymore. It took a concentrated effort to keep my eyes on Benedict's face.
"All thanks to your brilliant quick thinking," he muttered, sounding a little breathless himself, as his eyes roamed my face. My heart kicked up an extra beat, and against the better judgement in the back of my mind, I followed the impulse to let my hands drift up to rest on his arms.
Almost reflexively, like it was the most natural thing in the world, Benedict's hands came up to rest lightly on my waist. Slowly, he leaned forward, until our foreheads pressed together. He'd given me plenty of time to pull back, but I hadn't moved an inch.
"I... am about to say something that will greatly complicate our friendship," he said. I smiled, meeting his eyes as we remained face to face.
"By all means, do so."
He chuckled, a relieved smile growing on his own face. My heart sped up in my chest in anticipation of what I thought Benedict was about to say.
"I have been feeling this way for some time... I've thought about saying this to you for a long time, too. I should be more eloquent, but I'm struggling not to trip over my words..." My smile grew as I huffed a short laugh. Benedict, usually one of the most poetic and well-spoken people I knew, was struggling not to trip over his words. He huffed a little laugh, then continued. "I... have feelings for you. To be more precise, actually, I... I love you. I'm in love with you. And I think I have been for... for longer than I'd realized. You are such a wonderful and important part of my life, and you have been for so long. I can't imagine life without you, I- oh, please tell me I haven't just ruined our relationship."
I laughed, especially at the worried look on his face. He looked slightly more relaxed at my reaction, but not completely. I moved one of my hands from his arm to his chest, just above his heart, and gave him a soft smile.
"You haven't ruined anything, Benedict. I've been feeling the same way for at least as long as you have. I was too scared to ruin our relationship myself, so I never said anything... I'm glad you finally did."
He let out a gigantic sigh, relaxing backwards to rest his head on the opposite closet wall as his shoulders slumped.
"Oh, thank goodness. I can't imagine what I would've done if you hadn't felt the same way."
I giggled a little, leaning into him as he straightened up and pulled me closer. This time, I didn't stop myself from glancing down at his lips, which also meant I didn't miss the way they curved into a mischievous smile.
"...Does this also mean I can finally kiss you?" he asked. My eyes snapped back up to his, and I quickly nodded my head.
"I'll be incredibly disappointed if you don't."
Benedict grinned again, then wasted no time leaning in to close the distance between us. I met him halfway, and fireworks exploded in my chest as soon as our lips met.
I leaned even farther forward, into Benedict, and he pulled me closer as we deepened the kiss. My head spun, my entire world narrowing to the man I loved, who I knew loved me back, who I finally got to kiss. I don't know how far we would've gone before society's hovering rules floated back into our minds, but the door to our hideout swung open before we got the chance to find out.
My stomach swooped, this time with panic rather than butterflies. Benedict and I jerked apart, putting as much distance as possible between us in the tiny space, and I got ready to shove Anthony over if he'd somehow managed to find us. After blinking a few times while my eyes adjusted to the sudden light, however, I found a different Bridgerton sibling staring at the two of us.
Daphne stood framed in the doorway, her hands on her hips and an eyebrow raised. I glanced at Benedict, and found him looking just as shocked and sheepish as I felt.
"I was wondering how long something like this would take the two of you."
Benedict and I both stumbled over a few half-formed words. I had absolutely no idea what to say, and clearly, he didn't either.
"I came to tell the two of you that Anthony gave up. He's due for a visit to one of the neighbors, and he had no choice but to leave a few minutes ago. You two are safe, at least for now."
"...Thank you, Daphne." I managed to choke out. She nodded and then slowly, a grinned pulled onto her face as she glanced between me and Benedict again.
"You know, the two of you are very lucky both Anthony and I have been in similar situations before. And that I'm the one who found you."
"I take that to mean you won't be telling anyone?" Benedict finally managed to ask. Daphne shook her head.
"No. Although I'm sure I speak for everyone when I say I'm relieved the two of you finally realized the feelings you've been ignoring for far too long."
With that, she turned on her heel and walked away, leaving the closet door open behind her. Benedict and I turned to each other slowly, sheepish grins in place as he rubbed at the back of his neck.
"Well..." I started. "I suppose my idea for revenge on Anthony worked out better than imagined."
Benedict snorted, the tension and nerves finally breaking between us. He reached out and pulled me into his side, although with the door wide open, we didn't go farther than that.
"...I'm afraid that if I agree, I'm going to find myself running from my siblings after you've decided to prank them more often than I already do."
I grinned up at him, leaning into his side a little more. "That's a guarantee regardless, Benedict. If we act on these feelings and court, then-"
"There is no if."
I stopped short, the teasing grin falling from my face at the seriousness of Benedict's tone. He met my eyes steadily, absolute sincerity conveyed through his posture, tone, and expression.
"So long as you agree, I intend to marry you. I know we may need to court officially first, and that we can't simply be married tomorrow, but... for me, it's a when, not an if."
I straightened up slightly, smiling at Benedict more earnestly.
"Then you will definitely need to be prepared to run from your siblings with me after I've pranked them, much more frequently as my husband."
Benedict sighed dramatically, throwing his head back and slumping a little. I brought a hand up to my face to hide a laugh, especially as Benedict straightened up again and fixed me with a raised eyebrow and a smirk.
"Well, at least then, we'll be able to do what we want in the closets we hide in without fear of social scandal or violation of propriety."
I laughed, lightly whacking Benedict's shoulder as he grinned. The two of us wandered back into the rest of Aubrey Hall together, lighter and happier than I'd ever felt before.
Not even the looming issue of Anthony's return could change that feeling today.
****************
Everything Taglist: @rosecentury @kmc1989 @space-helen @misshale21 @diego42 @crepuscola
Bridgerton Taglist: @cherrybb-ily @dearhnymn @asgards-princess-of-mischief @babypurpledragon









