in terms of cosmere jews, what do you think is the prevailing view on the Weeping? I could see it going either way, as a mashiv haruach type of thing or a three weeks kind of deal.
Since the diaspora, holidays connected to agriculture or the holiday cycle weren't completely a thing. It does depend on whether we go on my and Spring's version of Cosmere Jews - where they come from their own planet - or we're just having Jews somehow exist on Roshar. And even within my and Spring's version, there's the question of how they keep the calendar. I do believe we ended up agreeing they'd use a local calendar due to the need for Pesach to be in the spring (which doesn't go well with how they do stuff in the southern hemisphere, but that's a different matter IMO). Due to that, Pesach is half a Rosharan year from the Weeping. So...
The weeping is actually around when their Rosh haShanah, Yom Kippur and Sukkot fall. Probably. So, more of a Mashiv haRuach approach. Though, quite honestly, with how Rosharan weather works, they either keep the "according to Eretz Yisrael" laws or have a very, very different system in place. One where Mashiv haRuach is more of a year round thing, while Morid haGeshem might be a Weeping only thing.
