โ๏ธ Writing Dialogue That Sounds Like Real People, Not Theater Kids on Red Bull
(a crash course in vibes, verbal economy, and making your characters shut up already)
Okay. We need to talk about dialogue. Specifically: why everyone in your draft sounds like theyโre in a high school improv group doing a dramatic reading of Riverdale fanfiction.
Before you panic, this is normal. Early dialogue is almost always too much. Too polished. Too "scripted." So if yours feels off? Youโre not failing. Youโre just doing Draft Zero Dialogue, and itโs time to revise it like a boss.
Hereโs how to fix it.
โโโโโโโ โฆ โโโโโโโ
๐ญ STEP ONE: DETOX THEATER ENERGY I say this with love: your characters are not all quippy geniuses. They do not need to deliver emotional monologues at every plot beat. They can just say things. Weird, half-finished, awkward things.
Real people:
interrupt each other
trail off mid-thought
dodge questions
contradict themselves
repeat stuff
change the subject randomly
Let your characters sound messy. Not every line needs to sparkle. In fact, the more effort you put into making dialogue โจperfectโจ, the more fake it sounds. Cut 30% of your clever lines and see what happens.
โโโโโโโ โฆ โโโโโโโ
๐ค STEP TWO: GIVE EACH CHARACTER A VERBAL FINGERPRINT The fastest way to make dialogue feel alive? Make everyone speak differently. Think rhythm, grammar, vocabulary, tone.
Some dials you can twist:
Long-winded vs. clipped
Formal vs. casual
Emojis of speech: sarcasm, filler words, expletives, slang
Sentence structure: do they talk in fragments? Run-ons? Spirals?
Emotion control: are they blunt, diplomatic, avoidant, performative?
Hereโs a shortcut: imagine what your character sounds like over text. Are they the โlol okayโ type or the โokie dokie artichokie ๐โจโ one? Now translate that into speech.
โโโโโโโ โฆ โโโโโโโ
๐ง STEP THREE: FUNCTION > FILLER Every line of dialogue should do something. Reveal something. Move something. Change something.
Ask:
Does this line push the plot forward?
Does it show character motivation/conflict/dynamic?
Does it create tension, add context, or raise a question?
If itโs just noise? Itโs dead air. Cut it. Replace it with a glance. A gesture. A silence that says more.
TIP: look at a dialogue scene and remove every third line. Does the scene still work? Probably better.
โโโโโโโ โฆ โโโโโโโ
๐ฅ STEP FOUR: REACTIVITY IS THE GOLD STANDARD Characters donโt talk into a void. They respond. And how they respond = the real juice.
Donโt just write back-and-forth ping pong. Write conflict, dodge, misunderstanding. If one character says something vulnerable, the other might joke. Or ignore it. Or say something cruel. Thatโs tension.
Dialogue is not just information exchange. Itโs emotional strategy.
Try this exercise: A says something revealing. B lies. A notices, but pretends they donโt. B changes the subject. Now youโve got a real scene.
โโโโโโโ โฆ โโโโโโโ
๐ STEP FIVE: PAY ATTENTION TO POWER Every convo has a power dynamic, even if itโs tiny. Whoโs steering? Whoโs withholding? Whoโs deflecting, chasing, challenging?
Power can shift line to line. That shift = tension. And tension = narrative fuel.
Write conversations like chess matches, not ping pong.
โโโโโโโ โฆ โโโโโโโ
โ๏ธ STEP SIX: SCISSORS ARE YOUR BEST FRIEND The best dialogue is often the second draft. Or third. Or fourth. First drafts are just you figuring out what everyone wants to say. Later drafts figure out what they actually would say.
Things to cut:
Greetings/closings ("Hi!" "Bye!"--skip it unless it serves tone)
Exposition disguised as chat
Obvious thoughts spoken aloud
Explaining jokes
Repeating what we already know
Readers are smart. Let them fill in blanks.
โโโโโโโ โฆ โโโโโโโ
๐ง STEP SEVEN: READ IT OUT LOUD (YES, REALLY) If you hate this step: too bad. It works. Read it. Mumbling is fine. Cringe is part of the ritual.
Ask yourself:
Would someone actually say this?
Does this sound like one person speaking, or a puppet show with one hand?
Where does the rhythm trip? Whereโs the breath?
If you canโt say it out loud without wincing, the reader wonโt make it either. Respect the vibe.
โโโโโโโ โฆ โโโโโโโ
๐ TL;DR: If you want your dialogue to sound like real people, let your characters be real. Messy. Annoying. Human. Let them interrupt and lie and joke badly and say the wrong thing at the worst time.
Cut the improv class energy. Kill the urge to be โจbrilliantโจ. And listen to how people talk when theyโre scared, tired, pissed off, in love, or trying not to say what they mean.
Thatโs where the good stuff is.
โrin t. // thewriteadviceforwriters // official advocate of awkward silences and one-word replies
P.S. I made a free mini eBook about the 5 biggest mistakes writers make in the first 10 pages ๐ you can grab it here for FREE:
โฆ A free (and actually helpful) guide to leveling up your first 10 pages โฆIf you're unsure whether your opening is โจdoing enoughโจ to hook re












