#deenas-johnson

We collected headcanon ideas to all the GM women, girls and femslash ships, then voted until we had our winners:

Madeleine lives!

Floreleine + Scarletmay polycule

Madeleine is a Vampire

The headcanons in complete text form can be found here:

Florence

Madeleine

Floreleine

ScarletMay

Sam & Emily

Multi

Send us an ask if you want to join the server to chat with other fans and/or join more games in the future!

Gunpowder Milkshake Fandom Primer

Feel free to use the headcanons as prompts for your own creation as long as you do so with credit to the blogger who wrote it!

Links to fic and art inspired by the headcanons below the cut, so the list will stay up to date :)

Killercule polycule (floreleine+scarletmay main couples, but they are all romantically together) - @floreleine - 2nd place in the game!

Scarletmay are dog people while Floreleine favour cats - @deenas-johnson

Emily figured out the librarians are all in love (one day the four of them try to explain it and after a lot of awkwardness, Emily is like oh yeah i figured it out the first day isn't this totally normal whatever) - @sarah-fiers - 6th place in the game!

The librarians all live at the library together - @floreleine

All three librarians started together - @floreleine

The two wings in the library were only furnished after Sam and Scarlet started coming more often – that’s also where they store the real books. - @verbumproxen

While Emily has already decided she wants to be a librarian, Sam would rather she take after madeleine, but a couple of her grandmas have other ideas - @bombsbaybeee

Anna May and Florence come from enemy crime families - @floreleine - 9th place in the game!

The librarians have odd sleeping habits because of their job (Madeline is an early riser, Anna May is a night owl, they don’t even know when Florence sleeps most of the time) - @sarah-fiers

Here are the headcanons for SAM & EMILY:

Sam being raised by cartoons and sugary foods is a result of her convincing Nathan that was how her mom raised her, when it was in fact the exact opposite - @marzipanilla

Emily will be a "librarian" in the future - @my-gaydar-is-on-point

Emily’s favourite milkshake flavour is strawberry - @deenas-johnson

Emily makes Sam finish high school, in exchange for her having to go to school. - @ussjellyfish

Sam really wants Emily to have a 'normal' childhood so tries to send her to school, and the school is endlessly confused by her family situation. - @ussjellyfish

Emily will be Sam’s apprentice - @floreleine

Emily's lactose intolerant, but she goes to the diner when Sam wants one anyway - @bombsbaybeee

MADELEINE headcanons:

Madeleine likes to wear lingerie - @floreleine

Madeleine's first kill was at an incredibly young age (much younger than the other librarians) - @marzipanilla

Madeleine lives - @floreleine - 1st place in the game

Madeleine’s a vampire! - @my-gaydar-is-on-point - 3rd place in the game!

They only had a funeral for Madeleine to fake her death (because of the Firm) - @floreleine - 7th place in the game!

Madeline comes back as a ghost (not in a spooky way, but in a fun 'i'm here to remind u to drink water and wear sunscreen' type of way) - @sarah-fiers

Madeleine grew up the most 'normal' and only joined the librarians after Anna May and Florence (and she knows most things from books instead of irl experiences) - @floreleine - 8th place in the game!

Madeleine is an adrenaline junkie who loves roller coasters - @deenas-johnson

The van is Madeleine's and she used to live in it before she joined the librarians (she still sometimes likes to hide in it for some peace and quiet) - @floreleine

Madeleine's a terrible cook (Florence regularly has to save the kitchen from her wife) - @floreleine

Blorbo (favorite character, character I think about the most) it’s Nicky 100% personally I think it’s the fact that he’s catholic and when I have a gay Catholic character I can project on I’m gonna do it (see ronan lynch)

Scrunkly (my “baby”, character that gives me cuteness aggression, character that is So Shaped) ok not exactly this definition because Nile is no baby but I love her so much like she means so much to me! She’s a Chicagoan, she’s my best friend, she’s dealing with the complexities of having been part of the US military…I just love her so much 😭😭😭

Scrimblo Bimblo (underrated/underappreciated fave) MY BELOVED LYKON BABY YOU DESERVE SO MUCH BETTER IM SO SORRY FOR HOW UNDERAPPRECIATED YOU ARE 😭😭😭 i will push forward the lykon cause until I fucking die!!!! He deserves as much love as all the other characters (this last part goes for Quynh as well)

Glup Shitto (obscure fave, character that can appear in the background for 0.2 seconds and I won’t shut up about it for a week) Celeste ;;_;;; I’m in love with her and her compassion…I help you today you help someone tomorrow…QUEEN SO TRUE 😭😭

poor little meow meow (“problematic”/unpopular/controversial/otherwise pathetic fave) Booker…need i say more?

horse plinko (character I would torment for fun, for whatever reason) Keane.

eeby deeby (character I would send to superhell) Kozak.

Neo I love you sm I love your vibes too 🥺🥺🥰🥰