Danny Fenton Gets Detention at Gotham Academy and Somehow Turns It Into a Support Group for Gotham Rogues
Danny Fenton gets detention on his second day at Gotham Academy.
Official reason: âdisruptive commentary.â
Unofficial reason: he told a substitute teacher that their âvibe felt like a hostage situation waiting to happenâ and then tried to give conflict-resolution advice mid-lecture.
Damian is also in detention.
For unrelated reasons.
They do not speak.
The room is quiet. Boring. Normal.
Then the window opens.
No one touched it.
Danny glances over. âOh. Hey.â
Damian immediately reaches for a weapon.
Because standing outside the third-floor window is a Gotham rogue who definitely should not be there.
âRelax,â Danny says. âHeâs not here for that.â
âThat is a criminal,â Damian replies flatly.
âYeah, but like⊠heâs having a moment.â
The rogue climbs in, looking less threatening and more⊠frustrated.
âI tried it your way,â he snaps at Danny. âDidnât work.â
Damian freezes.
âYou know this individual.â
Danny shrugs. âWe talked yesterday.â
âYou talked to a rogue.â
âYeah, he needed advice.â
This is already spiraling.
More spiraling happens when another figure appears at the window.
Then another.
Within ten minutes, detention has:
One vigilante-in-training (angry)
One civilian (unbothered)
Three Gotham rogues (confused, irritated, but oddly cooperative)
The teacher has not returned.
Danny claps his hands once.
âOkay, cool, everyoneâs here.â
Damian: ââŠEveryone?â
Danny: âYeah, weâre doing a follow-up.â
âA follow-up to what.â
Danny gestures vaguely. âBad decisions.â
One of the rogues points at him. âYou said if we didnât escalate, things would go smoother.â
âThey wouldâve,â Danny says. âYou skipped step two.â
âThere were steps?â
âThere are always steps.â
Damian is watching a known criminal argue about process with a teenager who should not be in charge of anything.
âWhy are you listening to him,â Damian demands.
The rogue pauses.
ââŠHeâs weirdly convincing.â
Danny nods. âThank you.â
This continues.
Danny mediates.
Not fights. Not threats. Just⊠talks.
He breaks down their plans like theyâre group projects that went off the rails.
âYouâre overcomplicating it,â he tells one. âYou donât actually want the chaos, you want the reaction to the chaos. Different problem.â
âYouâre focusing on the wrong target,â he tells another. âThatâs why it keeps blowing up in your face.â
At one point, he hands someone a piece of paper.
âWrite down what you actually want to happen,â Danny says. âNot the dramatic version. The real version.â
ââŠThis is stupid.â
âDo it anyway.â
They do.
Damian sits there, absolutely still.
Because this should not be working.
These are criminals.
They should not be calmly discussing motivations in a detention room like this is normal.
And yetâ
No one is fighting.
No one is escalating.
For once, Gothamâs chaos is⊠contained.
Directed.
Almost manageable.
Damian finally interrupts.
âYou are interfering with active criminal behavior.â
Danny looks at him. âYeah.â
âThat is not your role.â
âMaybe,â Danny says. âBut it helps.â
âIt is not sustainable.â
Danny shrugs. âNeither is what theyâre doing now.â
Silence.
One of the rogues raises a hand slightly.
ââŠSo whatâs step two?â
Danny smiles.
âGlad you asked.â
By the time the teacher comes back, the room is empty.
Except for Danny and Damian.
The window is closed.
Everything looks normal.
âWhat happened here,â the teacher asks slowly.
Danny brightens. âGroup discussion.â
Damian says nothing.
Because later that night, reports come in.
Fewer incidents.
Plans abandoned halfway through.
Rogues⊠hesitating.
Not stopping completely.
Just⊠reconsidering.
Damian finds Danny on the roof after school the next day.
âYou are altering behavioral patterns,â he says.
Danny leans back on his hands. âIâm talking to people.â
âThey are not people. They are threats.â
Danny looks at him, expression quieter than usual.
âTheyâre both.â
Damian doesnât respond.
Because he doesnât have a counter for that yet.
And that is deeply irritating.














