Dark Order and Hangman had an orgy together while making a movie. The movie wound up not getting made because the orgy scene was 4 hours long but couldn't be edited down because it was all important to the plot (according to Hangman).

John Silver and Alex Reynolds did hand stuff with Adam Cole.

Kenny Omega shamed Hangman for his alcoholism and had little to no sympathy for him (he has only vaguely apologized to Hangman for this).

Hangman had a horse names Hunter Horse Helmsley that Chuck Taylor psychically gave Hangman a nightmare about after his death.

Orange Cassidy's debut had a lights-out moment because Jungle Boy was messing with wires backstage.

Adam Cole was resurrected from the dead by a guilt-stricken Kenny Omega and canonically did not remember at first how he died (in a rare BTE-to-in-ring moment, Adam Cole revealed that he did, in fact, remember that the Bucks killed him and that was why he turned on them shortly before his first big break following injury).

Best Friends tried to kill Brandon Cutler because they ran out of bits to do (they instead mutilated Colt Cabana by mistake). They specifically wanted the killing to be a little bit sexual.

Kenny Omega has gone briefly insane several times in BTE, including one time when he fully imitated the Wedding Singer.

Luchasaurus thinks Barney the Dinosaur is racist.

Dark Order collectively has a crush on Wardlow.

Kenny became a weird, unusual version of the Cleaner because of prompting by Matt Jackson (who didn't realize he'd set Kenny down the path that would inevitably lead to him neglecting the Bucks, which in turn drove the Bucks to become the current rendition of the EVPs).

Nick Jackson has an alter ego 'Merch Freak' who can spontaneously force his friends to wear his merch.

Trent rinses his coleslaw because it's too sweet.

Hangman and the Young Bucks first started pulling apart because the Bucks refused to second Hangman in his match with Jericho in 2019 (they didn't realize at the time that Hangman was starting to suffer from the weight of his own insecurities).