An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works
The carnival was dead.
A haunting melody drifted through foggy air. Delicate metallic notes chimed, each one cold and mechanical, lingering just a heartbeat too long in the silence.
His eye scanned his surroundings.
Lights flickered across cracked asphalt, reflecting off warped metal and shattered funhouse mirrors. The faint hum of electricity vibrated beneath Damianâs feetâlike something still alive underground. Desperate. Restless. As if the souls of lost children stirred beneath the soil, reaching upward from forgotten graves.
He found the source of the sound, a black and white doll, painted porcelain, cracked and unsettling as it looked up from its expressionless eyes.
The music continued as he lifted from the broken path.Â
Damianâs gaze left from the black and white face and tracked the rows of his own reflection.
His face carried his fatherâs stoic restraintâjaw set, expression controlledâbut his eyes stared back in that unmistakable al Ghul green. Each reflection followed him precisely, every movement fluid, obedient. Him.
All of themâexcept one.
As he stared, a single reflection lagged half a second behind. Then it shiftedâjust slightlyâmoving with a will that wasnât his.
It smiled. Not warm. Not cruel. Expression without heart.
There was no clear way out. Years of neglect had swallowed the exits, paths eroded into nothing. From somewhere beyond the rusted rides and sagging structures, he felt watchedâeyes lingering from the granite hillside bordering the grounds.
Silent. Patient.
The mechanical melody slowed to an uneven grind. One final note rang out. Then nothing.
Still, Damian moved. Wandering. Searching for a way home.
He stopped when he came upon the flyers.
A sea of gray faces stared back at him from weathered paper, stapled to warped boards and peeling walls. Missing children. Their names blurred, their photos fading with exposure and time.
One face remained clear.
EmilyâŠ. Emily Crane.
The name echoed, hollow and insistent.
And suddenly, he was no longer wandering.
Damian stood at the center of a crime scene.
A ride half-collapsed nearby. The haunted house loomed in the distance, its structure groaning softly as if breathing. Police tape fluttered weakly in the wind, sectioning off dark pools that soaked into the ground. Flashbulbs erupted in sharp bursts, freezing moments in harsh white light. Evidence bags lay scatteredâblades, hair, scraps of fabric, small personal effects stripped of meaning by plastic and tags.
Every instinct sharpened.
Study. Catalog. Observe.
His gaze moved with precision. Angles. Distances. Placement. And thenâsnow.
Fresh and untouched. Itâs familiar biting scent unearthing a memory he wanted to forget.Â
The scene felt familiar in a way that made his stomach tighten. The sleek sound of a blade slicing through frozen ground flashed through his mind. A batarang striking true. Snow turning red.
Not by his hand.
The memory cut deeper than he expected.
Then he saw it. A doll.
Black and white. Porcelain cracked. Its painted eyes stared aheadâempty, accusing. As gray and lifeless as the faces on the flyers.
It lay there, forgotten, small, fragile, heavy.
It reminded him of what he had been once. Still lost. Still trapped inside something he hadnât chosen.
The carnival blurred.
Lights smeared. Tape dissolved. The world fell away into an abyss.
It felt like being swallowedâ overtaken by something vast and unspeakable.
Like screaming underwater.
Each breath felt borrowed. Each second sinking deeper.
When sensation returnedâif it could be called thatâeverything was dark. The air was cold and damp. Metal pressed in from every side, close enough to steal breath. Shadows crowded the walls where they shouldnât exist, thick and suffocating.
The room smelled of iron and rust. Blood. Sharp and invasive, clinging to his skin like a memory he could never scrub away.
There were sounds.
Soft sobs. Small cries. Voices pleading for lives that existed before this place.
Sounds he never forgot. Sounds that found him every time a child criedâproof that his body remembered what his mind tried to bury.
Panic surged.
Not the kind that sharpened the mindâbut the kind that hollowed it out.
He crawled back. And stopped.
Cold bars bit into his palms. A cage.
Too small. Too close. Built for something waiting to die.
A light flickered on.
And there he wasâ
No.
Damianâs thoughts reeled, correcting instinctively. Youâre not Schott.
He wasnât the Dollmaker.
He was the clown.
Perfectly still. Black-and-white costume stained with something dark. Everything about him was wrongânot chaosâ hand, but by design. His features were exaggerated past comfort: limbs too long, frame too thin, proportions stretched like a cruel joke. A pointed, witchlike nose marked with a single black dot.
And that grinâ Too wide. Too empty. A smile carved where hope should have been. The same heartless smile heâd seen in his rogue reflection.
His eyes locked onto Damianâs.
Unblinking. Watching. Waiting.
A metallic clang echoed. A lock shifted.
Footsteps brushed the floor. Slow. Predatory. Inevitable.
Damianâs instincts screamedâplan, strike, escapeâbut his body refused him. Here, he wasnât the predator. He wasnât even in control.
He was a child again.
Small. Trapped. Exposed.
The doll appeared beside the cage, propped just outside his reach. Its cracked porcelain face tilted upward, smiling wider nowâas if it understood.
This wasnât chaos. This wasnât madness. This was intentional.
The violence wasnât a means to an end.
It was the end.
And this place⊠This place wasnât simply the old toy factory where Anton Schott twisted innocence into abominations. It was something worse. Something personal. A hell he wasnât meant to escape.Â
The clownâs shadow crept closer, stretching across the bars. The room reeked of iron and cold oil. The dollâs gaze followed Damianâs, unbroken.
He tried to think. To calculate angles. To find weakness.
But the frightened child inside himâwho remembered the cages, remembered being watchedâfroze.
âIf it were me in one of those cages⊠would you have killed him then?â
The question echoed as it clawed itself from the depth of his memories.Â
His heart hammering. Ribs too small. Breath too shallow.
The clownâs grin never faded.
Another dim light flickered to life across the cold room.
It wasnât sterile.
Damianâs breath caught as his gaze dragged upward, taking in the biological fragments that lined the wallsâmeat and marrow arranged with deliberate care. Not random. Not frenzied. Curated. The greatest tragedies, dissected and displayed.
His stomach lurched. For the first time, he wanted to fold in on himselfâto disappear into the corner of the cage like the others had.
Then he saw the writing.
Blood streaked across the wall in uneven strokes, still wet. Still fresh.
Not a warning.
A declaration.
CONTROL IS SUBJECTIVE
The letters bled downward, staining the concrete in slow crimson threads. The blood had soaked so deeply into the wall it felt permanentâas though the room itself had absorbed the message long ago.
Damian stared.
His breathing slowed without permission.
The cage hadn't changed. Yet something about it felt less certain.
Smaller.
Or perhaps he was.
His gaze dropped.
Black paint coated his hands. Thick. Fresh.
It pooled in the lines of his palms and beneath his fingernails, creeping into every scar and crease as though it had never belonged anywhere else.
He turned one hand over. Then the other.
The paint wasn't drying. It wasn't dripping. It looked absorbed.
Like it belonged there.
A memory surfacedânot fully formed, but close enough to feel. A brush dragging across canvas. The sweet smell of oil paint.
The careful pressure of a hand making choices. His choices.
Control is subjective.
The thought arrived quietly. Not spoken by the clown. Not written on the wall.
His own.
The realization hollowed him out. Because the paint wasn't evidence of something done to him. It was evidence of something done by him.
The doll sat motionless beside the cage, its cracked porcelain face turned toward him.
Waiting. Remembering.
The clown remained exactly where he had been. Perfectly still. Watching.
And somehow that was worse.
No threats. No violence. No pursuit.
Only certainty.
The same certainty Damian felt every time he looked at the canvas in his mind and recognized the hand that created it.
His hand. Control is subjective.
The words echoed again.
And for the first time, Damian couldn't tell whether the cage was holding himâ or whether he had spent years building it himself.
The clown tilted his head. Not a movement. A punctuation mark.
The grin never widened.
It didn't need to.
The world dropped out beneath him.
âDAMIAN!â
Dick's voice tore through the darkness like a lifeline thrown into deep water.
â
Read More đ
