The Quiet You Bring (fluff/mild angst)
π Bayverse Leonardo/Female Reader π
A/N: This is a commission Iβve done for @bkwrm523 ππ’
Enjoy!! π
CWs: Fluff, mild angst, mutual pining, themes of low self-esteem & insecurity, hurt/comfort, confessions, first kiss, and a happy ending. All characters are aged-up.
The sound of the lair is something youβve grown to love.
You can pick out the humming of Donnieβs servers from his lab, the clatter of Mikey in the kitchen attempting some culinary monstrosity, and the rhythmic thuds from Raphβs room where heβs pulverizing his punching bag.
Itβs the sound of home.
Youβre on the couch, with April sitting beside you, scrolling through her phone as she does some research for a news report sheβs working on. You, on the other hand, are supposed to be drawing. But your pencil has been still for the better part of ten minutes. Your gaze, as it so often does when youβre here, has drifted and snagged on a single point of focus.
Leoβs near the entrance to the dojo. Heβs performing a series of kata, his twin katanas a blur of silver. He moves with a lethal grace that seems utterly incongruous with someone of his size and bulk. The light catches the intricate patterns on his skin, intense concentration etched onto his face.
Heβs now practicing a move that could disarm a dozen armed men. Yesterday, your biggest challenge was navigating a self-checkout machine that kept insisting there was an βunexpected item in the bagging area.β A sigh, soft and wistful, escapes you before you can stop it. Itβs quiet, but April catches it.
βStaring at your boyfriend again?β she teases, her eyes still glued to her phone, the corner of her mouth twitching upwards.
Heat floods your face, a mortifyingly swift blush you know is turning you the color of a ripe tomato.
You snap your head back down to your sketchbook, your pencil suddenly feeling clumsy in your now sweaty hand. βHeβs not my boyfriend, April,β you mumble, the words sticking to your tongue. You shade a section of your drawing with far more vigor than necessary, nearly tearing the paper.
βCould be,β she says, finally looking over at you. A knowing, slightly exasperated smirk plays on her lips. βYou just have to, you know, actually talk to him. Form complete sentences. Make eye contact for more than two-point-five seconds.β
βI talk to him!β you protest, your voice squeaking on the last word. And you do. Youβre the queen of monosyllabic communication. You say βHi,β and βThanks,β and occasionally, a daring βGood night.β Landmark conversations, every single one of them.
April just raises an eyebrow. βHoney, Iβve seen you have deeper conversations with your houseplants. Seriously, whatβs the hold-up? Heβs a good guy.β
You risk a glance back at him. Heβs finishing his forms, sheathing his swords. For a moment, he bows his head as he regulates his breathing. Heβs the leader. The responsible one. The one who carries the weight of his entire family on his shoulders. Heβs noble and serious and so devastatingly handsome in a way that makes your stomach do frantic little flips.
βThatβs the problem,β you confess to April, your voice thick with a hopeless sort of admiration. βHeβs not just a βgood guy.β Heβs β¦ Leo. He fights aliens and robot-samurai and saves the city on, like, a biweekly basis. Heβs a hero.β
You look down at your own hands, at the smudges of graphite on your fingertips and the chipped polish on your nails. You think of your small apartment, your part-time job at the library, your perfectly normal life that was so completely and irrevocably upended the day you stumbled into Aprilβs worldβand, by extension, the turtlesβ.
βAnd what am I?β The words tumble out now, a torrent of insecurity you can no longer contain. βIβm just β¦ me. Ordering coffee makes me nervous. I trip over my own feet on flat surfaces. Heβs β¦ heβs so completely out of my league itβs not even funny. Weβre not even playing the same sport. Heβs in the Super Bowl and Iβm in the stands, spilling soda all over my lap.β
April gives you a sympathetic look. βI donβt think he sees it that way.β
βHow could he not?β you sigh, finally closing your sketchbook. βItβs just a fact.β
You donβt notice the change in the room. You donβt see the way Leo, who had finished his cooldown and turned to head towards the kitchen for a bottle of water, had frozen mid-step. You donβt see the way his shoulders tense, and his eyes widen just a fraction. Because he heard.
Every self-deprecating word.
He remains perfectly stillβlistening until April changes the subject and the two of you are deep into another conversation. Only then does he finally move, a troubled expression on his face as he heads back to his room.
The next few days are β¦ strange.
The change in Leo is almost imperceptible at first, so subtle youβre convinced youβre just projecting your own ridiculous hopes onto him.
When you all gather to watch a movie, he doesnβt take his usual spot in the armchair. Tonight, he bypasses it completely and settles on the couch. Not right next to youβthat would probably make your heart combust on the spotβbut close. Close enough that his arm is only a few inches from yours where it rests on the back of the couch.
Your body is ramrod straight, your popcorn forgotten, your entire being focused on not accidentally brushing your hand against his. And so, you spend the entire two-hour runtime of the cheesy sci-fi flick acutely, painfully aware of his proximity.
A few nights later, the strangeness escalates. During dinner, while Mikey is proudly presenting his latest masterpiece, Leo speaks. Directly to you.
βDid you finish that book you were reading?β he asks. His voice is a low, pleasant rumble.
You jump, nearly dropping your slice of pizza. A week ago, you mentioned the book off-handedly to Donnie. Youβre floored that Leo not only heard but actually retained that information.
βUh, y-yeah,β you stammer, your eyes darting down to your plate. βIt was β¦ it was great.β
βWhat was it about?β he presses, his tone genuinely curious.
Your mind goes completely blank. You canβt remember the plot, the characters, or even the title of the book youβve spent the last few days completely engrossed in. All you can think is, Leo is talking to me. Donβt say something stupid. Donβt say something stupid!
βSpace,β you finally squeak out. βAnd, um β¦ feelings.β
Raph snorts from across the table. βSounds deep.β
Leo shoots his brother a glare that could melt steel before turning his attention back to you, his expression softening. βIt sounds interesting,β he says, and he sounds like he means it.
Mikey wiggles his eyebrows at you. Donnie simply pushes his glasses up his nose, a flicker of something curious in his eyes as he observes the interaction.
The small, focused interactions continue to pile up.
He asks your opinion on a strategic problem heβs mapping out, valuing your βoutside perspective.β He makes a point of saving you a cup of the good tea Master Splinter keeps for special occasions. You even receive a compliment on one of your sketches, with him telling you that you have a way of βseeing the beauty in ordinary things.β
The invitation to the dojo was the most terrifying, though.
βI need a spotter,β heβd said, his voice even.
You stand awkwardly near the door as he goes to the center of the mat and moves into a one-handed handstand. The sheer power required is breathtaking. He has muscles of corded steel, and his entire body presents a study in focus.
βYou see?β he grunts, his voice tight with effort. βTell me if my alignment shifts.β
You have no idea what proper handstand alignment looks like, but you nod anyway, your mouth dry. βYouβre β¦ youβre good. Very β¦ straight.β
A low chuckle escapes him, causing him to wobble for a second. βEloquent as always.β He isnβt mocking you; his tone was warm, amused. He holds the pose for another ten seconds before landing silently on his feet. βThanks. It helps to have someone watching.β He gives you a small smile that makes your knees weak.
Each small gesture is a fresh wave of confusion.
Your shy, insecure heart canβt process it. A part of youβa hopeful, fluttering partβthinks that maybe April was right. But the much louder, more dominant part of your brainβthe part that has been in charge for most of your lifeβscreams that this is all an elaborate act of pity. He overheard your pathetic little confession and now he feels sorry for you.
Heβs just being nice, trying to make the timid little human girl feel included. The thought is so mortifying it makes you want to crawl into a hole and never come out.
The breaking point comes a week after your conversation with April. Youβre in the kitchen, trying to wash your dinner plate. Sometimes, you swear the faucet has the pressure of a fire hose. Youβve sprayed a fine mist of water all over the front of your shirt. Frustrated and embarrassed, you let out a huff of annoyance.
βNeed a hand?β
You spin around, your heart leaping into your throat. Leo is standing in the doorway, leaning against the frame with a casual ease that you find utterly captivating.
βN-no! Iβm fine,β you stammer, turning back to the sink and scrubbing at your plate with unnecessary force. βJust β¦ wrestling the faucet. Itβs winning.β
He chuckles. He pushes off the doorframe and walks towards you. The kitchen suddenly feels claustrophobic. He reaches around you, his body a solid wall at your back, his large hand easily gripping the nozzle. With a simple twist, the water pressure evens out to a gentle, manageable stream.
βIt sticks sometimes,β he says, his voice soft and impossibly close to your ear. βYou have to know the trick to it.β
You are frozen solid. Your entire being is focused on the scant inches between your back and his plastron. You can smell the clean, freshly washed scent of his skin, of whatever body wash he uses. Itβs intoxicating and completely overwhelming. Your brain has officially short-circuited.
βThanks,β you whisper, rinsing your plate in record time and practically launching it into the drying rack.
You need to flee. Now.
You turn to squeeze past him, your eyes to the floor. βI should, uh β¦ I have to go.β
βWait.β
His voice is gentle, but it stops you in your tracks. Reluctantly, you lift your head. Heβs looking down at you, his blue eyes searching your face. Thereβs no pity in them. Thereβs something else, something you canβt quite decipher. It looks like β¦ frustration? And something softer.
βAre you avoiding me?β he asks, his voice quiet.
Your throat closes up. βWhat? No! Why would IβIβm not.β Your denial is weak and unconvincing even to your own ears.
A sigh escapes him. βI heard you,β he says, his gaze unwavering, pinning you in place. βThat night. On the couch. I heard what you said to April.β
Oh.
Oh, no.
The floor beneath you might as well have given way. Every ounce of blood and color drains from your face, leaving you cold and clammy. You want to run, to scream, to teleport back to your apartment and never show your face here again. You squeeze your eyes shut, bracing for the inevitable letdown.
βYou think Iβm out of your league,β he states.
You can only manage a tiny, jerky nod, your eyes still closed. You canβt bear to look at him.
βLook at me,β he says, his voice still soft, but with an undercurrent of command you canβt ignore.
Hesitantly, you open your eyes. He hasnβt moved. Heβs still standing there, looking at you with an intensity that steals the very breath from your lungs.
βYouβre wrong,β he says simply, bluntly.
Your brow furrows in confusion. βWhat?β
βYouβre wrong,β he repeats, a little more forcefully this time. βYou have it completely backward.β He steps closer, forcing you to crane your neck to maintain eye contact. βYou see this?β He gestures to himself. βYou see a hero. A leader. You know what I see when I look in the mirror? I see the mistakes Iβve made, the times Iβve put my family in danger, the pressure of trying to be what everyone needs me to be.β
His voice drops lower, becoming more vulnerable than youβve ever heard it. βMy brothers β¦ theyβre my entire world. But they look at me and see the Leader. Raph sees a rival to challenge. Donnie sees a strategist to consult. Mikey sees the fun-police who needs to lighten up. Splinter looks at me and sees the dutiful son, the one who must uphold his honor. They all need something from me constantly.β
He pauses, his eyes boring into yours. βBut you,β he says, his voice softening again, βwhen you look at me β¦ I donβt know. Itβs different.β A small, fond smile touches his lips for a fleeting second. βYou look at me like Iβm just Leo. When youβre here, you bring this β¦ quiet with you. A sense of peace.β He takes a deep, shuddering breath, as if steeling himself for an ice-cold plunge.
βYou think Iβm out of your league? Do you have any idea how terrifying it is to talk to you? Iβm trained to face down adversaries. Iβm not trained for β¦ this.β He gestures vaguely between the two of you. βI spend ten minutes trying to work up the courage to ask you about a book, and my heart is pounding harder than when I was facing down Shredder. You think Iβm some perfect, noble hero? You make me so nervous I can barely think straight.β
You stare at him, your mouth slightly agape, your mind reeling. Your carefully constructed realityβthe one where you are the insignificant, star-struck human and he is the unattainable, heroic mutantβis shattering into a million pieces. Heβs nervous? Around you?
βYouβyouβre serious?β you breathe.
βIβve never been more serious in my life,β he says, his gaze fierce and true. βThe reason I started talking to you more wasnβt pity. It was because I heard you say you thought you werenβt good enough, and it was the most fundamentally incorrect thing I had ever heard. I wanted to prove you wrong. I wanted to show you that I see you. The real you. The one who has the gentlest, most peaceful soul Iβve ever had the honor of knowing.β
Tears prick at the corners of your eyes. But also tears of disbelief, of overwhelming, heart-swelling relief.
βI β¦ I like you, Leo,β you say, the confession finally, finally breaking free. βI like you so much it physically hurts sometimes.β
A slow, breathtaking smile spreads across his faceβand itβs the most beautiful thing you have ever seen. βGood,β he rumbles, the sound full of its own relief. βBecause I really, really like you, too.β
He lifts a hand, his large palm moving with incredible slowness, as if giving you every chance to pull away. He gently, reverently cups your cheek, his thumb stroking over your skin. You lean into his touch instinctively, your eyes fluttering shut as you savor the contact.
βSo,β he murmurs, βjust to be perfectly clear β¦ weβre in the same league?β
You open your eyes, a watery laugh bubbling up from your chest. βYeah, Leo,β you whisper, your hand coming up to rest on his wrist, feeling the powerful tendons beneath his skin. βWeβre in the same league.β
βGood,β he says again, and then he closes the small distance between you.
His kiss is nothing like you could have imagined in your wildest, most vivid daydreams. Itβs not fierce or demanding, or clumsy. Itβs tentative, and gentle, and so unbelievably sweet it makes you dizzy. You melt into it, all your fear and insecurity and self-doubt dissolving, replaced by a radiant, soaring happiness that feels bright enough to light up the whole lair.
When he pulls back, he rests his forehead against yours. You stay like that for a long, perfect moment, just breathing each other in. Itβs just the two of you, in your own quiet universe.
From the doorway, a loud voice breaks the spell.
βFINALLY!β
You both jump apart, your faces flushing. Mikey is standing there, a grin stretching from ear to ear, giving you two enthusiastic thumbs-up. Peering over his shoulder is Donnie, who adjusts his glasses and offers a satisfied smile. And leaning against the far wall, arms crossed over his chest, is Raph. He rolls his eyes dramatically, but you canβt miss the ghost of a genuine smirk playing on his lips.
βTook you long enough,β he says, before shaking his head and heading back towards the dojo.
Leo groans, hiding his face in his hand for a second in embarrassment. But when he looks back at you, heβs smiling. He takes your hand, his fingers lacing through your smaller ones, a perfect, comfortable fit.
βSorry about them,β he says, his thumb stroking the back of your hand. βThey have no concept of privacy.β
βItβs okay,β you reply, your own smile so wide it makes your cheeks ache. βTheyβre your family.β
βWelcome to the family then,β he says.
He leads you back to the couch, sitting down so close your knees touch. Thereβs a movie playing, but neither of you is watching.
βSo,β he says, turning to face you fully. βNow that weβve established weβre in the same league β¦β He looks down at your joined hands, a contemplative look on his face. Then he looks back up at you, his eyes full of a warmth and affection that makes you feel like the most cherished person in the world. βWould you be interested in seeing a game? With me? Not in the stands, though. Maybe a private box?β
βA private box?β you laugh.
βYeah,β he says, his gaze soft. βMy favorite rooftop, a couple of pizzas, and no brothers allowed. Howβs that for a first date?β
You lean your head on his shoulder. βSounds perfect.β












