Colgate Total Whitening vs. Optic White: Which Toothpaste Should You Buy?
When choosing between Colgate's two leading whitening toothpastes - Total Whitening and Optic White Advanced - it helps to understand their key differences. Both effectively whiten teeth, but they take different approaches that make each better suited for specific needs.
Colgate Total Whitening (4-Pack)
This toothpaste offers a balanced approach, combining moderate whitening with comprehensive oral care. The fluoride formula not only removes surface stains but also actively fights cavities, gingivitis, and bad breath throughout the day. Its gentler formulation makes it ideal for those with sensitive teeth who still want whitening benefits. The classic mint flavor provides lasting freshness without being overpowering. At 5.1 ounces per tube in a 4-pack, it offers excellent long-term value.
Best for: Those seeking gradual whitening plus complete mouth protection.
Colgate Optic White Advanced (3-Pack)
For more dramatic results, Optic White uses a hydrogen peroxide formula that penetrates deeper to remove stubborn stains from coffee, tea and wine. While it contains fluoride for cavity protection, its primary focus is whitening performance. Users often notice visible brightening within 1-2 weeks. The "Icy Fresh" flavor delivers an intense cooling sensation. The tradeoff is that some users may experience increased sensitivity, and the tubes are smaller at 3.2 ounces each.
Best for: Those prioritizing fast, noticeable whitening above other features.
The Bottom Line
Total Whitening works best as an everyday toothpaste that happens to whiten, while Optic White serves as a more specialized whitening treatment. For optimal results, many dentists recommend using Optic White at night and Total Whitening in the morning. Consider your primary goal (maintenance vs dramatic whitening) and sensitivity levels when choosing.
Buy Colgate Total Whitening on Amazon
Buy Colgate Optic White Advanced on Amazon
This post contains affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you make a purchase through these linksβat no additional cost to you. I only recommend products I genuinely believe in, and any commissions earned help support this blog. Thank you for your support!
