Why Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin (spin-off) Is A Bad Idea
Wanted to make a post on this for awhile and more people need to talk about how bad of an idea this is. First of all, we all know this just a cash grab by milking the PLL name. It hasnât even been 2 years since PLLâs last spin-off The Perfectionists aired. Hopefully we can all agree that leaving the franchise alone for a few years would be best, donât you think so?
Riverdale creator Roberto Aguirre Sacasa will be the one to lead this circus into a possible downfall. Now say whatever you want about this not being disrespectful to Marlene etc but it IS. Itâs disrespectful to the PLL legacy as well. And quite frankly, itâs disrespectful to Sara Shepard too because this new show wonât be following the books whatsoever. I donât think nobody who didnât have a part in creating this universe should have a part in a spin-off just because they have an obsession with the show. I donât have any faith in this being good after what Roberto has done with his shows. Specifically Riverdale. Every thing that he has written turned corny. And heâs quite petty as well:
Iâve noticed that the theyâre trying to connect with the original PLL fan base as well and theyâre failing as they do that. Just by using teenagers again, âItâs not what you think bitches -Aâ, Millwood sounding like Rosewood etc. Itâs just a cheap effort. The Perfectionists fans werenât even able to GRIEVE since it hasnât been long since it was cancelled. They basically received a slap in the face. This also kind of ruins any chance of us getting a revival with the OG cast because letâs face it, theyâre not going to want to do one with original sin on air run by a different showrunner plus all of the cast unfollowing the official PLL page after that announcement basically tells you theyâre not for it lol.
I think itâs disgusting how they literally went behind Marleneâs back with doing this considering she had no knowledge of the situation and was pretty upset just by her tweets. Every one is right about how she didnât âcreateâ this PLL world and that it was Sara Shepard, but Sara had no part in creating the PLL universe as a series. Which is what Roberto (without any knowledge) is taking over. She was not being unprofessional either. Now I know she canât legally take part in it considering her contract with 20th Century Fox, but itâs nasty how they can go and do that and not give her a heads up and just letting her hope for a season 2 for the perfectionists when Warner Bros knew that it was never happening while this was probably in the works.
Which is also probably the reason why Freeform cancelled The Perfectionists. Clearly this show has been in the works probably for awhile maybe a year while The Perfectionists was airing. There would be no other reason as to why it was cancelled. Low ratings donât count considering every Freeform show had about the same. But even with The Perfectionists, the fans didnât care for the newbies minus Alison and Mona being in it. But even that wasnât enough. So why do these people think a whole new cast is going to reel back in the fans? Every one wants the original cast back and thatâs just a fact. Clearly not for another few years though.
From the plot they gave, it sounds like a Riverdale plot to me and honestly is not appealing. Teen girls getting harassed because of the sins their parents committed? Come on now.
WHY is Pretty Little Liars even in the name???? It should be a separate show considering itâs a new cast and story. how do they plan on making it apart of the universe??? Mentioning what happened in Rosewood? How far into the future will this take place in? Itâs just so fucking random and has nothing to do with PLL.
This franchise unfortunately already has two unsuccessful spin-offs. It needs to be put to rest for now. Thereâs a 50/50 chance with how this new spin-off will go because it is on a streaming service ran by HBO. So I guess you can expect quality and it has a higher chance of it having more views than how it would be on cable. But that doesnât necessarily mean the writing will be good. I mean I guess weâre going to have to wait and see how this turns out because they didnât give much to judge off on.
