The Lantern Beyond the Pines
Chapter Four: Watching Eyes
_____
Morning arrived beneath a blanket of low, gray clouds. The kind that promised rain but never quite delivered.
You stood on the porch of your little house, stretching the stiffness from your shoulders before stepping into the street.
Another day. Another list of things that needed fixing. The town never really ran out.
As you locked your front door, your eyes drifted toward the porch boards. Nothing. No footprints. No sign that anyone had stood there the night before.
You frowned to yourself.
"Of course."
Why would there be?
The diner was already alive with conversation when you stepped inside. Coffee. Bacon. The clatter of dishes. For a few precious minutes each morning the town almost forgot where it was.
"About time." You looked over to find Randall occupying his usual chair near the window. "You waiting on me?"
"No. You've been staring at the door." He tilted his head toward the glass, lifting his cup.
"I was staring outside."
"Mhm." He didn't dignify that with a response. You poured yourself a mug of coffee before dropping into the seat across from him. "You look awful."
"You say the sweetest things." Your eyes rolled, lips meeting the bitter liquid.
"You sleep?"
"Enough."
"Liar."
You smiled into your coffee. "So I've been told." A corner of Randall's mouth twitched. Barely. You caught it anyway.
Donna entered the diner with the energy of someone who'd already solved three problems before breakfast. "There you are."
You looked up. "Morning?" She pointed a finger at you. "The fence behind the clinic."
"What about it?" You already knew where this was going. She was lucky you liked her enough.
"It didn't survive the storm."
"I'll look at it."
"I knew you would." Donna nodded once, satisfied. Then looked toward Randall. "You." He sighed immediately. "What?"
"You're helping."
"No, I'm not."
"Yes, you are."
"I had plans."
"You didn't."
"...Fuck..." Another sip, this time, for his nerves if anything. Donna smirked. "Exactly."
By midmorning the fence looked considerably better. Mostly because Randall had eventually stopped complaining and started working.
"You missed."
You looked over.
"I absolutely did not."
"The post's crooked."
"It isn't."
He walked over, crouching to inspect it.
"...Huh..."
"What?" Your head tilted. With your work, you were rarely wrong. This would be not different.
"It isn't."
You grinned. "I know."
"Don't get used to that."
Both of you worked mostly in silence.
Hammer.
Nail.
Saw.
Wood.
The familiar rhythm settled comfortably between you. Randall suddenly spoke. "You've been distracted." You paused mid slam. "Have I?"
"Mhm."
"Since when?"
"A couple days."
"I've just been busy."
"You've always been busy." He drove another nail into the fence. "You keep looking toward your house."
Your grip tightened around the hammer. "Well..shit"
"You do." He swung again. Another nail into the board.
You forced a shrug. "Probably making sure I locked the door."
"You always lock the door."
"I know."
"So that's not it."
Silence.
He glanced sideways. "You gonna tell me?"
"Nothing to tell."
"Hm." He moved to grab another board. He let it go. For now.
The afternoon passed with the usual rhythm of small repairs and shared burdens. Near sunset, Boyd gathered several people in the center of town.
"We've got a problem." Everyone turned. Boyd rested one hand on the hood of an abandoned sedan. "This thing's blocking half the road."
You stepped forward. "We pushing?"
"We're pushing."
A few people moved into place. You braced your hands against the rusted frame.
"Ready?" Boyd's voice rang. A chorus of nods. "Push!" Metal groaned. Mud shifted beneath your boots.
The car lurched only a few inches before stopping again. "Again!" You dug in harder. The muscles in your shoulders burned.
Beside you, Randall grunted. "Who leaves a damn car in the middle of a road?"
"The people who drove into a nightmare?"
"Fair point."
One last shove. The sedan rolled clear. A cheer rose from the group.
Small.
Tired.
Earned.
Boyd wiped sweat from his forehead. "Good work." You brushed dirt from your palms. "Think that's everything?"
He looked toward the horizon. The sun had already begun to sink. "For today."
The town scattered with practiced urgency. Windows closed. Doors locked. Curtains drawn. The familiar ritual.
You reached your porch just as the first shadows stretched across the road. The talisman hung exactly where you'd left it. Inside, your home greeted you with quiet.
You checked every window. Every latch. Then set the kettle on to boil. Tonight, you told yourself you weren't expecting anyone. You even believed it.
For almost twenty minutes.
A soft voice drifted through the glass. "You repaired another fence Darlin." You closed your eyes. "You really do notice everything."
"No." Cowboy's voice remained calm. "I notice you."
Your hand froze around the handle of your mug. The words weren't spoken with affection. Or hunger. Or triumph. Just simple certainty.
You walked to the window, stopping a respectful distance away before drawing the curtain back an inch.
He stood exactly where the porch light faded into darkness. Hat low. Pale hands resting over his silver buckle. His gaze was already on you.
"You continue to work."
"You continue to watch."
"I arrive after."
"I know." A beat of silence. Cool air met your skin, air escaping from the tiniest cracks in the window seam. You didn't pay it much mind. You'd mess with it later. "You still notice."
"I observe what changes."
Your eyes searched his face. "And I keep changing the town."
"You do." His answer came immediately. "As does the town change you." The remark lingered.
Not because it frightened you. Because you weren't sure he was wrong. Your fingers lingered on the edge of the curtain. "The town changes everyone."
Cowboy remained still beneath the porch light. "It does."
"You sound certain."
"I am."
You looked past him, toward the empty street The darkness had swallowed the road almost completely. Only the warm glow spilling from your front window reached the porch.
"You've watched people for a long time, haven't you?" The cloth wrinkled between your thumb and index.
"I have."
"And?"
His head tilted. "And?"
"What happens?"
His gaze drifted toward the neighboring houses. "They arrive. You know that part." It looked as if he were studying a map, instead of a community. "They fear."
"I know." You mumbled, all too familiar with his statement. It was the worse part about this place. A permanent blanket of emotion.
The Cowboy gaze shifted slighty; from the Matthews' house, to Sara's. "They hope. Sometimes, they despair." The words came one after another. Measured.
Without emotion. As though he were reciting the seasons.
"And then?" Your question was near a whisper.
His eyes settled back on yours. "They die."
Silence.
No cruelty. No satisfaction. Simply...a fact. You swallowed. "That's a terrible way to look at people."
"It is."
"You don't care?"
Another pause.
"Never did."
Your eyebrows knit together. "You just..." You searched for the right words. "You make it sound inevitable."
"It often is." The answer landed heavier than you expected. Not because it was heartless. Because there was no malice in it. Only certainty.
You folded your arms against the chill. "Has anyone ever talked to you like this before?" His eyes narrowed ever so slightly, not in irritation, but thought. "No."
"No one?"
"They usually beg."
The matter-of-fact way he said it made your stomach twist. You imagined terrified people crying through windows, pleading for help that would never come. The Cowboy continued. "Or they curse."
"I can imagine." You chuckled to yourself. Randall, Randall would be the one to throw the whole dictionary at the creature.
"They threaten."
"Does that bother you?" He met his gaze once again.
"No." And he met yours.
"What about me?"
A pause. "You ask questions." His shirt rippled soft in the calm wind.
"I ask too many."
"I did not say that Darlin."
"You're avoiding the question."
"I answered it."
"No." You couldn't help the small smile tugging at your lips. "You answered the one you wanted."
"I did." His smile matched your own.
"You know that's frustrating?"
"I've observed."
The kettle had long since gone cold. Neither of you seemed to notice. You found yourself studying him.
The pristine white shirt. The polished boots. The silver buckle catching the light. Not a speck of dirt. Not a wrinkle.
"You always look..." You hesitated. He waited. "Clean." He looked down at himself.
"I suppose."
"You hunt. You walk through the woods. You never look like you've been through the woods." Your eyes scanned for even the tiniest speck of dirt. Or even, blood.
"I have not considered it."
"You've never wondered why?"
"No."
"...Huh..." You frowned thoughtfully. "I've never seen any of you" Your voice trailed off. "Dirty."
He regarded you for a long moment. "You notice things." The observation caught you off guard.
"I guess I do."
His head dipped in the smallest nod. "That's why we continue speaking." You blinked. "Because I notice things?"
"You notice. You ask. You continue." Each word was deliberate. Most people would've found them meaningless. Somehow, you didn't.
A breeze stirred the trees. Leaves rustled softly. Farther down the road, another figure emerged from the darkness.
A woman in a pale dress.
She walked slowly, almost gracefully, before stopping near the edge of your yard. She looked toward Cowboy. Then toward your house. Neither of them spoke. The woman smiled.
Not at you.
At him.
It wasn't warm. It wasn't kind. It was knowing. Cowboy didn't acknowledge her. He didn't even turn his head.
After another few seconds, she continued down the street until the darkness swallowed her whole.
You realized you'd been holding your breath. "Friend of yours?"
"They're all familiar."
"You didn't answer me."
"I did."
"No. You answered around it."
The faintest hint of amusement touched his expression. "That I did Darlin."
You let out a quiet groan. "You're impossible."
"So you've mentioned."
The conversation drifted into another comfortable silence. Your gaze wandered to the clock on the wall. "You should probably go."
Cowboy looked at the clock. Then back at you. "Why?"
"Because you've been standing there for..." You checked again. "...Almost two hours." He seemed genuinely surprised.
"Has it been?"
"You didn't notice?"
"No."
"You were just..." You gestured between the two of you. "...talking."
"I was." Something about that answer lingered. Not because it was sweet. Because it sounded like he'd only just realized how much time had passed.
He lifted two fingers to the brim of his hat.
"I shall leave."
"You don't have to." The words escaped before you could stop them. The silence that followed felt enormous.
You stared at him. He stared at you. Your heart skipped. "...I mean..." You cleared your throat. "If you want."
Cowboy studied your face. Long enough that you wondered if he was trying to understand what you'd meant.
Finally, "I will return."
Not tomorrow. Not soon. Just., "I will return." He stepped backward into the darkness. One step. Then another. His pale hat disappeared among the trees.
You stood at the window long after he'd gone. "What was that?" You weren't sure whether you were talking about him or yourself.
Outside, the night continued exactly as it always had. Inside, for reasons you couldn't explain, your house felt just a little quieter than before.


















