Previously a study identified a list of domestication-associated genes in modern humans by comparing their genome with extinct human species. These genes overlapped with domesticated animals but not with their wild equals. This finding sheds light on the possibility of human domestication.
The self-domestication hypothesis suggests that during evolution, modern humans underwent a self-induced domestication process that anatomically resulted in a lighter built skeleton, a more juvenile look (smaller brow ridges, nasal projections, teeth, and cranial capacity), and a larger brain when compared to their earlier counterparts. In other words, this process encourages selection against aggression and preserves the “cuter” attributes.
One way of explaining the domestication process is the neural crest hypothesis of domestication, which proposes that domestication is attributable to alteration in migration and the mild deficiency of neural crest cells during embryonic development. Neural crest cells (NCC) are responsible for inducing and developing neuroendocrine cells, pigment cells, neurons and glial cells of the sensory, sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous systems, and many skeletal and connective tissue components of the head.
“Neurodevelopmental disease modeling for the study of human evolution” was the unique approach adopted by a recent study that dissects the role of BAZ1B in domestication as well as affirms the neural crest hypothesis.
The study considered a cognitive disorder, namely Williams syndrome (WS). WS shares many similarities with domestication-related modifications. The parallels between the two include decreased aggression, hypersociability, reduced head size, elfin face, pointy ears, small jaw and teeth, short stature, accelerated sexual maturity, etc. Hence, WS is synonymous with hyper-domesticated human phenotype. The syndrome is caused by hemideletion of 28 genes at the 7q11.23 region. BAZ1B (a chromatin regulator) gene plays a crucial role in NCC maintenance and movement; intriguingly, one copy of this gene is missing in individuals with WS.
To evaluate the contribution of BAZ1B in making us “cuter,” i.e., domestication/WS-related facial modifications, neural crest stem cell lines were cultured, and the gene activity was altered in each cell line. The paper concluded impairment in NCC migration and outgrowth upon a decrease in BAZ1B, proving the involvement of BAZ1B in NCC development in humans. Additionally, it was found that the reduced expression of the BAZ1B gene led to distinct facial features (similar to WS), establishing the gene as an essential driver of facial appearance. Thus this paper provided the first experimental evidence for the neural crest hypothesis as an explanation to domestication where BAZ1B is one of the genes driving this process. Furthermore, the knockdown of BAZ1B also affected EDN3, MAGOH, and ZEB2 expressions. These genes are associated with behavioral changes as a result of domestication.
Studies indicate that these genes are also involved in the development of cognitive processes like language or theory of mind. Thus further introspection can bring about a clear picture of the anatomical, behavioral, and physiological alterations resulting from self-domestication in humans.
Reference:
Zanella, M., et al. (2019). Dosage analysis of the 7q11.23 Williams region identifies BAZ1B as a major human gene patterning the modern human face and underlying self-domestication. Science advances, 5(12), eaaw7908. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aaw7908















