Are We Still Friends? â Part Three
Pairing: Reader x Azriel
Summary: Azrielâs attempts at an apology fall short, Cassianâs advice backfires, and confrontations force both you and Azriel to face uncomfortable truthsâthough not the same ones.
Warnings: angst. a heavy grudge, a male incapable of owning up to his mistakes, a well-meaning but wrong-steering best friend, verbal fighting, physical fighting, brief mentions of blood
Word Count: 8.5k
this was going to be two parts but... for the drama, ive decided to offer a feast and not just a meal
Part Two â Series Masterlist â Part Four
âč â¶ đ§· â¶âčÂ
Azriel hadnât meant to let it sit for this long.Â
His shadows had been needling him for days, hissing reminders at the edge of his mind: Fix this. He intended to. He just didnât know how. There were too many eyes on him now, too many people that expected his great, grand apology.Â
It was hard to focus on anything else. Even when he was with Selene, her words barely touched him. His mind was consumed by the unease that gnawed at him, the constant pull of you, somewhere, still angry over what had happened.
Azriel wanted to ask Selene about her words. Why theyâd taken root in his mind, why heâd echoed them back to you. But he didnât. He let Selene talk, smiled when she asked for his opinion, and tried to let the softness of her lips on his drown out the unease.
He didnât know exactly why it felt so much harder with youâ felt harder to argue, felt even harder to apologize. Everything else in his life, every delicate situation, every broken, jagged thing, he could attempt to handle with steady hands. But youâevery time he stepped near you lately, it felt like stepping onto unstable ground. One wrong move, and everything shifted beneath him.
His shadows had made sure to remind him, trailing after you through the house, feeding him fragments of your clipped words to Mor, the slam of a cabinet door when you thought no one was paying attention. They werenât even subtle about it anymore, curling around his ears like smoke, whispering your whereabouts.
Heâd tried small thingsâleaving you treats, a smoothie for breakfast, or a croissant on a plate with your name carefully written on a napkin. But every time he returned to check, they were untouched. Once, he found the croissant flattened and crumpled, as if youâd squeezed it with a tight fist before tossing it back onto the plate. His shadows confirmed you were angry that night, their murmurs suggesting no coincidence in your evening spent with Mor.
Since then, every instinct told him to stay away and retreat, to wait until heâd figured out the right thing to say instead of stumbling through this mess. But waiting had gotten him here, hadnât it? And now he was scrambling to undo weeks of silence. He thought, maybe, he should have something written out. Something properly planned, so that he knew what he wanted to tell you. But every time he thought about what to say, his mind came up blank. After hours of failure, heâd convinced himself that, with you, it would come naturally. It always had.
Or, at least, thatâs what he kept repeating as he made his way downstairs, finding you in the kitchen.
You didnât look up right away, but you knew he was there.Â
âAre you sure you want to be in here without a chaperone?â you said, slicing into an apple slowly. âWhat if something happens?â
Shadows swirled around his shoulders. Angry, they whispered. As if he didnât already know.
âStop,â Azriel said. âCan we just... stop with the comments. Please.â
âWhy?â You said, finally tossing a glance his way. âIs it bothering you?â
The look on your face was nothing like he expected. It wasnât just anger. It was exhaustion, too. He didnât like it, the way the shadows under your eyes and the stiffness in your shoulders spoke louder than anything youâd said to him in days. Didnât like that heâd probably been the one to put that exhaustion there.
âYes,â Azriel finally responded. âIt is bothering me.â
You let out a laugh, something low and humorless, and it twisted in his chest. Should he apologize for making you lose sleep, too? Heâd already failed at the rest of itâwhat was one more thing to add to the pile?
Azriel cleared his throat. âCan we talk?â
âNow you want to talk?â
His fists clenched at his sides. The familiar burn of frustration, the heat of guilt, rose up his throat. âHow was I supposed to talk to you before when youâd just ignore me or say something snarky and leave?â
You stilled at his words and Azriel was almost tempted to embrace the small flicker of relief he felt. He should have apologized sooner, yes, but you had been avoiding him fervently. He convinced himself he wouldnât have been able to apologize before now, anyways.Â
âOkay,â you said, setting the knife down and leaning against the counter. âWell, Iâm here now. So what do you want to say?â
Azrielâs eyes flicked to the knife instinctively. It was far enough from your hand that he probably didnât need to worry. Probably. Not that he thought youâd do anythingâthough there was that one time Cassian had nearly stabbed him with a butter knife. Heâd been significantly less angry than you were now. The memory did nothing to ease Azrielâs nerves. He pushed the image away.
This was itâhis chance to fix things. To say all the things heâd been rehearsing in his head. But the words didnât come. Instead, he found himself saying, âHow was the meeting with Keir?â
The second the words left his mouth, he wanted to grab them out of the air and shove them back down his throat. He could see it in the way your expression shiftedâsomething sharp and disbelieving cutting across your face. Azriel didnât need his shadows to tell him heâd screwed up again. The words had barely landed, and already he was bracing for the fallout.
âThatâs what you wanted to talk about?â
Azriel froze. His shadows curled tighter around him. Stupid, stupid. He swallowed, desperately trying to correct it. There was no going back. âRhys said I should expect some tension at the next meeting. I wanted the full picture.â
âThe full picture?â You repeated darkly. âWell the full picture wasnât great, Azriel. Because you werenât there. And because I was pissedâbecause of you.â
Azriel nodded, swallowing hard. Idiot. âRight. I shouldnât have asked that. I shouldâveââ He stopped himself. No, he couldnât fix that now. He needed to focus on what mattered.
âIâm sorry,â he said, finally, the words leaving his mouth like rocks tumbling down a hill. He hated the way it soundedâweak, like he didnât mean it. But he did. He just didnât know how to make you believe it. Azriel continued, the apology already unraveling in his head. âFor how you feel.â
âOh,â you said softly, but there was a thick sarcasm in your voice. âYouâre sorry for how I feel?â
Azriel rushed to correct himself. âI didnât mean it like that.â
âThen what did you mean?â You shook your head, letting out a quiet, bitter laugh. âDo you even know what youâre trying to tell me?â
âYes.â
âThen what are you sorry for?â
Azriel cursed himself for the hundredth time. Why was this so hard?
Because it was you, he heard his own voice reply, because he couldnât bear the thought of failing you again. He knew he was failingâknew it in the sharp edge of your voice and the way your eyes narrowed every time he opened his mouth. And still, the right thing to say stayed maddeningly out of reach.
âIâm sorry that your feelings got hurt.â
His shadows slowly loosened, trailing down his body like they didnât want to be associated with him anymore. He didnât blame them. You blinked slowly at him, that look of exhaustion softening your features.
âThatâs not an apology, Azriel. Thatâsââ You cut yourself off, shaking your head. âYou know what? Nevermind.â
Azriel was transported back to the night of the fight, remembering how youâd said similar words then, too. He tried to salvage it again, but you were already moving, wiping the cutting board with a hurried motion. You didnât notice as your apple, barely sliced, rolled off the counterâs edge. His shadows were there almost instantly, catching the fruit before it fell.
You reached out, and for a brief moment, your shoulders softened as you grabbed it from their hold.
âWhere are you going?â Azriel asked. He wondered if his voice sounded as desperate as he felt. As frustrated.
âTo train with Cassian,â you replied, still not looking at him. Your hand paused on the counter, and you glanced over your shoulder. âDo you think I should stop by Nesta first? Make sure sheâs okay with me being around her mate? I wouldnât want to ruin their relationship too.â
Azrielâs chest tightened. âCan we stop this?â
âNo,â you replied swiftly, and Az could have sworn he heard a crack in your voice.Â
And then the silence stretched. You ate the small slices of apple as you put things away, the quiet dragging on as he stood there, still unable to speak. Finally, you stopped and looked at him. He tried to offer a smile, something to soften the weight in the air. But you just frowned.
âDid you expect to wait this out? Wait until I got over it?â
Azriel shook his head, his voice low. âNo. I never thought that. I justââ
âJust what?â
âI donât know what you want me to say.â
You stared at him for a long moment, like you were seeing him for the first time, and the disappointment in your gaze made his chest feel tight. He should have been able to find the right words. But it didnât matter anymore, not in this moment, not as you let out a small, bitter laugh, nodding as if something inside you had finally broken.Â
âAlways so afraid of saying the wrong thing that you never say the right one.â
Azriel opened his mouth, desperate to correct himself, to make it right, but the words just wouldnât come. He had never considered that beforeâat least, not with you. Heâd never thought he needed to say the right things, never cared enough to learn how.
âI never realized how much of an asshole you could be,â you said, with a final, almost dismissive glance. âI guess some females are into that.â
And then you were gone.
âč â¶ đ§· â¶âčÂ
Training couldnât have come at a better time.
You needed to hit somethingâneeded to feel that release. Not in a petty, frustrated way, like slamming your fist into a wall, but in the desperate, raw way that left you aching. It was the only way to escape your frustration and, maybe, remind yourself that you were still you, despite how Azriel made you feel.
And for a while, it worked.
Cassian had spent centuries mastering the language of battle, the unspoken rhythm of war. He could read the tension in a stance, spot when someone's body didnât follow through with the mindâs intentions. He didnât get enough credit for it, you thought, his ability to read someone without words. He was looking at you now, with that critical eye, head tilted slightly, like he was waiting for you to crack.Â
âAlright,â Cassian grunted as he parried another strike. âWhatâs on your mind?â
You ducked beneath his swing. âNothing,â you said, deflecting the question with a swipe of your sword. Too fast, too aggressive.
Cassian dodged it easily, raising a brow. âRight. Because ânothingâ is exactly what makes you swing like youâre trying to decapitate me.â
The corner of his mouth quirked up, but you didnât laugh. You werenât in the mood for his teasing, no matter how good-natured it was.
âItâs nothing. Seriously.â
He rested the flat of his blade against his shoulder. âCome on, spit it out before you take my head off for real. Iâll pester you all day.â
You sighed, pacing a few steps away. Heâd wait. He definitely would. And there wasnât much point in pretending anymoreâhe clearly knew you werenât fine. Continuing to train like this was useless when your head was so unfocused. Avoiding the topic wasnât helping either. At this point, everyone knew what was going on. Hell, they all seemed more bothered by it than Azriel.
Still, youâd been dodging these conversations. Talking about it felt...stupid. Saying it out loud would make it realâall the messy, painful feelings youâd been shoving down would be out there, staring back at you like some pitiful mirror. Your conversation with Azriel this morning had only made your bitterness stronger.
But Cassian was watching you, expecting, and it was nice, in a way. Having someone care this much. Maybe it would be easier to talk to him. Mor had helped, sure, but her comfort recently came in the form of dragging Azriel through the dirt. It didnât actually solve anything.
"Itâs this stupid thing with Az," you muttered finally. "Iâm starting to feel like he doesnât actually care about me."Â
Cassian leaned on the hilt of his sword. âWell, thatâs not true.â
You leveled him with a stare, your body tensing as a surge of frustration ran through you, hot and heavy. âIt isnât? He talked to me for the first time today and didnât even apologize. Not properly. Just asked about Keir.â
Cassianâs expression softened. âHe gets wrapped up in his own head about things. Probably just embarrassed, you know? Doesnât know how to approach the situation.â
Youâd run that possibility through your mind a hundred times. Mor had even said it herself. But it didnât help with the ache, the anger. It was hard to believe your spymasterâso fearless, so eager to throw himself into the fireâwas struggling to talk to a friend. Out of all the hard things Azriel had done, surely a simple apology wasnât beyond him. Youâd forgiven him for so much, had let things go because he was your friend. But you were tired of letting it go. He had the perfect opportunity to apologize, to properly acknowledge how heâd hurt you, and he hadnât taken it.
âEmbarrassed by what? Accusing his friend of something so absurd?â
Cassian tilted his head in subtle agreement, like he too thought the word absurd was right for the situation. âI think Az doesnât want to be seen as...whatever he thinks people see him as. Like heâs incompetent in love. Or that he canât handle his shit.â He rolled his shoulders, sighing. âHeâs defensive. When heâs cornered, he reacts badly. Itâs not about you, Y/n. You know that, right?â
You knew that. Of course you did. But it didnât feel like a proper explanation this time. It didnât feel like enough.
âBut it feels like it is about me. He listened to her. He took her word, over mine." Your fists clenched involuntarily. "And the way he actedâlike I wasnât worth considering, like my opinion doesnât matter. Iâve known him for centuries. Sheâ" You paused, taking a breath, "Sheâs barely been in his life. And he immediately assumes that my care for him is because I just want something from him. That itâs some selfish, self-serving thing. His whole job is to see through lies, Cass. He didnât even second-guess her.â
âIâm sure he doesnât actually see it like that. He probably just reacted out of instinct. Itâs Azriel, Y/n, heâs complicated. "
âShit, Cass, way to play sides.â
Cassian sighed, stepping closer. âIâm not playing sides. Iâm trying to help. Az makes stupid decisions. Half the time, I donât think he even understands why. I donât want you driving yourself crazy trying to figure it out. Itâs not worth it.â
âThen what am I supposed to do?â you snapped. âJust wait it out? Move on? Thatâs not happening.â
The words came out sharper than you intended, and guilt pricked at the edges of your conscience. This wasnât Cassianâs faultâhe didnât have to ask, didnât have to care. But lately, your anger over everythingâover Azâfelt like a thorn lodged so deeply under your skin that the irritation seeped into everything. You were struggling to control it.
It was a small blessing there werenât any court matters to handle for the time being. Rhys was likely still preoccupied with Keirâs incessant whining about your last outburst.
Still, it felt like acid rising in your throat, a bitter burn you couldnât swallow down, even as Cassian opened his mouth to respond. The words were spilling out of you before he could say anything.
âIâm not even mad about this one fight anymore,â you started, the grip on your sword slipping as your fingers unfurled. The blade clattered to the ground, the sound loud enough to make Cassian flinch. âItâs everything. All of it. He never apologizes for anythingâhave you noticed that? Like, ever. And Iâve let it slide because thatâs just Azriel, right? Quiet, brooding Azriel, whoâs somehow aboveââ
Cassian raised a palm out. âAlright, alright, stop,â he said. âYouâre going to drive yourself crazy. Itâs not worth it.â
You exhaled sharply, realizing you were halfway to a full-blown rant.
He stepped closer, giving you a knowing look. âListen, you canât force him to apologize properly. You just...canât. You have to let him come to it on his own.â
Your teeth clenched. âI shouldnât have to.â
Cassian sighed, rubbing the back of his neck.
âI agree. Believe me, I agree. But until he figures his shit out, maybe we focus on what you can change.â
âLike what?â
âI donât know. What else is bothering you?â
You let out a humorless laugh. âIt would be easier to list what isnât bothering me right now.â
Cassian tilted his head again, considering. âDoes it bother you that Selene sees you as competition?â
You blew a strand of hair out of your face. Did it bother you?
Azriel had believed her instantlyâdisregarded you with a swiftness that stung. Heâd accused you of selfishness, of something youâd never been with him. But Seleneâs opinion of you, the thoughts sheâd planted in his mind, those bothered you too. You hadnât realized it until now.
She didnât know you.
And yet, her words had curled under your skin, sitting heavy and raw, making you ache in a quiet, tired way. Worse, theyâd made you overthink every interaction with Azriel since. Youâd spent so much of your life trying to be the diplomat, choosing empathy even when it suckedâwhen it drained you. You wanted to like Seleneâgods, you wanted to like the people Azriel cared for, even when it felt impossible. But she hadnât even given you the time of day.
âI donât like that Iâve been vilified somehow,â you admitted with a frown. âI donât want to feel like Iâm fighting for his attention or validation. Itâs not like that.â
Cassian gave a small, knowing smile. âI know itâs not.â
âItâs not fair.â
âNo, itâs not.âÂ
He paused, clearly mulling something over, then asked, âDo you want to hear what I think?â
You gave him a wary look. âI feel like youâre going to tell me anyway.â
âCorrect,â he said, grinning. Then he sobered. âAz aside...I think Seleneâs reaction makes sense.â
You blinked at him, incredulous. Was he serious right now? A sharp heat rose in your chest. âOkay, well, thatâs clearly choosing sidesââ
âHear me out,â Cassian said quickly. âI mean, look at you, Y/n. Iâd be jealous of you too if I were her. Youâre beautiful, smart, someone Azriel deeply cares for. Hell, Iâd probably be a mess.â
Your lips pressed into a thin line. âSo, because Iâm so wonderful, Iâm responsible for her insecurities?â you asked dryly, arching a brow.
Cassian shook his head. âNo. What Iâm saying is that this might be the one aspect of the situation you can change. The one thing you have control over. Maybe talking to her would help. Clear the air.â
You mulled over his suggestion. Maybe he had a point. Maybe talking to Selene would help. Not just to ease the tension, but to give Azriel room to come to youâto clear the air between you both. If you did thisâif you took the first stepâmaybe heâd finally take you seriously. Apologize for dismissing you so easily, so carelessly. You could find a way to move on, comfortably, with Selene in his life. Right?
It wasnât like the situation could get any worse.
"Okay," you murmured, more to yourself than to him. "Yeah. Maybe Iâll talk to her."
âč â¶ đ§· â¶âčÂ
Cassian was waiting for Azriel as he stepped out of the townhome, his massive frame leaning against the railing. One glance at the general was enough to confirm it: Cassian wasnât there to exchange pleasantries. NoâCassian stood with his arms crossed, his wings partially flared, exuding the barely-contained anger Azriel recognized all too well.
âWe need to talk,â Cassian said.
Azriel resisted the urge to roll his eyes. He tightened his fists, shadows curling around them instinctively, obscuring his hands from view. Not now. Not tonight. He had no energy for thisânot for Cassianâs righteousness or whatever lecture heâd come prepared to deliver.
âIâm not in the mood, Cass,â he said flatly, brushing past him.
âToo bad.â Cassian stepped into his path, blocking him with ease. âI didnât endure an hour of Mor yelling at me for you to decide you canât have a conversation.â
Azriel paused, his brow furrowing. âWhy was Mor yelling at you?â
Cassian crossed his arms. âBecause of you.â
âGreat,â Az muttered. âWhat have I done now?â
âI gave Y/n some advice that, in hindsight, wasnât great. Mor made the situation a lot clearer for me. Now Iâm here to make sure you clean up your mess before anyone else slips.â
The mention of your name made Azrielâs chest ache in a way that felt too raw. Heâd told himself he wouldnât think about you tonightânot your voice, not your expression when heâd spoken to you this morning. But here was Cassian, dragging it all to the surface like a wound being forced open.
âI donât think this is any of your concern,â Azriel said coldly, stepping around Cassian in a last-ditch effort to leave.
Cassian didnât budge, spinning on his heel and following. âIt is my concern because youâre my friend. And Y/n is my friend.â
Azriel could feel his shadows tighten their hold, whispering, urging him to end this. He wasnât sure if they meant the conversation with Cassian or the situation entirely. Azriel could only control one of those.
âCass, leave it alone,â he said, his voice low, barely masking the warning there.
âNo,â Cassian responded immediately. âYou did something shitty and you need to own up to it, Az.â
Azrielâs jaw tightened. âSometimes friends fight,â he ground out. âSometimes we get on each otherâs nerves, like youâre getting on mine now. Itâll settle.â
âThis isnât going to âsettle.ââ Cassianâs voice rose. âYou didnât just get on her nervesâyou offended her.â
The words hit harder than Azriel had anticipated.
âBecause the idea of having feelings for me is so offensive? Am I that repulsive?â
The words slipped out before he could stop them, the question jagged, biting. He hadnât meant to say that. He wasnât sure where it had come from.Â
Cassian blinked, his anger giving way to confusion for a moment before his brow furrowed. âWhat the hell are you talking about? Donât twist this into something it isnât.â
Azrielâs chest tightened, a sudden rush of heat creeping up his neck. His outburst had come from nowhere, and now, Cassianâs eyes were full of confusion and something elseâsomething close to pity. Azriel felt small under it, a flush of embarrassment prickling down his body. He wanted to look away, to escape.
He needed to leave.
Think later. Process later. Just get out of here.
Azriel squared his shoulders, forcing himself to meet Cassianâs gaze with as much indifference as he could muster. âAre you done now? Selene is waiting for me.â
Cassian stepped closer, his wings flaring in frustration. âSelene can deal with a few lost minutes of Azriel time. Weâre talking.â
âNo,â Azriel said, voice flat, his gaze turning icy. âYouâre talking. Iâm leaving.â
He moved to step past Cassian, but the larger male blocked him again.
âIs this some weird self-pity thing?â Cassian demanded, his tone growing sharper. âThinking youâre not worth being forgiven so you donât even try?â
Those words hit a nerve.Â
Azrielâs anger sparked instantly, snapping through his ribs like a whip. He couldnât decide if it was directed at Cassian or himself. But Cassian didnât understand. None of them did.
âCass, just let it go.â
âNo,â Cassian shot back. âYou always do this. You make decisions that are selfish. You push people away because you think itâs easier, and itâs not. Itâs bullshit.â
It wasnât easierâit was never easier. But what was Azriel supposed to say? That it was better than risking more damage? That every decision he made, no matter how distant or cold, was the only way he knew how to protect the people he cared about?
âCassianââ
The slap came out of nowhere.
Azrielâs head snapped to the side, his shadows scattering in shock before reforming around him. Slowly, he turned back to Cassian, his eyes blazing.
âWhat the hell was that?â
âSorry,â Cassian said flatly. âMustâve been the wind.â
Azrielâs lip curled. He opened his mouth to respond, but a second slap landed, harder this time.
âWould you stop that?â Azriel growled, his wings flaring slightly, the shadows around him vibrating with his tone. âDonât touch me.â
Cassian stepped closer. âWhy?â he asked, mockingly. âThis is what you deserve, right? If youâre so terrible.â
The third slap was the breaking point.
Azrielâs fist flew, connecting with Cassianâs jaw in a blur of movement. The force sent Cassian stumbling back a step, but he recovered quickly, his retaliation swiftâa sharp uppercut to Azrielâs ribs.
They fought like brothersâwild, messy. Not about technique, but about something else. Azriel wasnât sure why Cassian needed this release, but he could feel itâthe desperate need behind every punch. And Azriel⊠Azriel didnât realize it at first, but he needed it too.
He was an Illyrian, no matter how many times he tried to convince himself otherwise. Fighting cleared his mind. Whatever Cassian was trying to achieve, whatever he needed to prove, it was working.
Azriel barely registered the sting of each hit. The ache in his ribs, the burn in his musclesâit all blurred into the same tight, unrelenting pressure in his chest. Like there was no room left for air, for thought, for the gnawing guilt that had dug its claws into him and refused to let go. Cassian tackled him to the ground, pinning him, both of them struggling for breath.
âThis is stupid!â
âI agree,â Azriel spat, shoving him off. âGet off me.â
âNo, you!â Cassian said, pushing himself to his feet. âYouâre stupid.â
Azriel sat up slowly, chest heaving as his shadows curled protectively around him.Â
Cassian shook his head, wiping blood from his lip. âYouâre better than this, Az. So be better and properly fuckinâ apologize. If not for you, for meâso my mate will stop glaring at me every time I say your name.â
Azrielâs gaze dropped to the ground, the weight of Cassianâs words sinking into him like a slow burn. His fists clenched at his sides, but he said nothing. Offered nothing.Â
Cassian didnât stop. âGods know Y/n has done enough for you. Put up with enough. Weâve all done shitty things. But you know what? You take the hit, you own it, and you try to be better. You canât lead with self-loathing forever.â
Azriel sat there longer than necessary, long after Cassian had walked away. People passed byâsome casting glances his way, most not bothering to look at allâbut he didnât move. Didnât feel the flicker of shame he mightâve once felt at sitting there, bloodied and bruised, shadows curling restlessly around him.
The sting in his cheekbone from Cassianâs knuckles pulsed dully, but it wasnât enough to distract him from the gnawing thoughts taking root.
Maybe it wasnât the fear of you rejecting his apology that held him back. Maybe it was the fear that you wouldnât.
That youâd accept it.Â
That somehow, heâd manage to make it up to you. That things would settle for a while, until he inevitably did something worse. Something irreparable.
He was terrified of succeedingâof pulling you back in, of you continuing to see something in him that he wasnât. That youâd keep believing in this illusion, this version of him heâd somehow convinced you existed.
For centuries, it felt like heâd been holding his breath, waiting for the inevitableâwaiting for you to see him as he truly was. And if he made this right, if you forgave him, it would only give him more time to fail you again.
âč â¶ đ§· â¶âčÂ
You were walking without a proper destination in mind.
Youâd never been to it, but Azriel had once mentioned that Selene worked at a flower shop near the Palace of Thread and Jewels. Heâd first run into her on one of his free days, when heâd stopped by a few of his favorite parts in the city.
This area made sense. It was near his usual route, tucked away in a cozy corner of the city. As the scent of flowers suddenly enveloped you, you heard Seleneâs unmistakable voice. Relief surged through you; youâd found the right place.Â
You thought back to your conversation with Cassian. You knew you werenât in the wrong, that this current visit wasnât expected of you. But it was something you could control. Youâd wanted to get to know Selene better anyway. You prepared yourself, putting on a smile and stepping towards the door, but thenâ
âI mean, is he really worth all that effort?â
This was a voice you didnât recognize. It curled around you, something about it making your stomach clench.Â
A small sigh. âAzriel?â
This time, the voice belonged to Selene. You froze, rooted to the spot. Any inclination to quit eavesdropping washed away at the sound of his name. You felt a tightness in your chestâan almost primal urge to run in there, to stop the conversation before it even began.Â
âYeah,â the second voice pressed, âHeâs a freak, Sel. Hot, sure, but a total freak. And so intense all the time.â
For a moment, there was silence. And then, Seleneâs voice, almost reluctant, like she was holding back. âWellââ
Her friend interrupted. âAnd those shadows? Donât they freak you out?â
A sound of disgust, maybe a shiver, followed her words. Something cold rushed through you, crawling beneath your skin, and for a moment, you didnât know whether you wanted to shout or run. Or maybe both. Anger churned in your gut, and the calm, composed facade youâd been carefully maintaining on the walk here began to crack, slipping away piece by piece.Â
âHey, knock it off,â Selene replied, her voice soft. âHe surprises you. Heâs sweet. He makes me happy.â
Her friend snorted. âHas it been an ego boost for you, then?â
âI mean, yeah,â Selene admitted quietly. âBut thatâs not all of it. Things with him actually arenât⊠great right now. He canceled on me again tonight. I think itâs because he had some kind of fight with Y/n.â
The mention of your name stole the breath from your chest, and your body constricted almost involuntarily.Â
Her friendâs voice was full of disbelief as she asked, âHe actually told you?â
âNo,â Selene said softly, âIâI heard them. I feel really bad, butâŠâ
The next sound was unmistakableâthe sharp intake of breath from her friend, a squeal of sorts.
âDid you actually use the listening charm I gave you? You little minââ
Something snapped in you as the words registered. A listening charm. A strange, gross invasion of privacy. And to think you had felt bad standing here, eavesdropping on their conversation in a public store, of all places. Youâd been this close to giving her the benefit of the doubt.
You stormed into the shop, the door slamming behind you, and both voices froze. You barely registered Seleneâs friendâs wide-eyed realization, the quiet âOh shitâ leaving her lips as she turned toward Selene.
Your focus was on Seleneâon her and no one else. She stood there, an image of calm beauty that twisted something deep inside youâa type of beauty that felt somehow wrong, as if it were too polished, too perfect, for the situation. Her dark hair framed her face, her delicate features still and pale as she stared at you. The color drained from her face the moment your gaze locked with hers.
âDo you want to explain what I just heard?â you asked, your voice tight, sharp, biting. âOr should I just tell you what Iâve gathered?â
Silence.Â
Her friend opened her mouth to protest, âI donât think you have any right coming in here andââ
âI think this is a conversation for me and Selene,â you said coldly, not bothering to spare her a glance.Â
Selene blinked a few times before she turned her head and offered her friend a small, almost reluctant nod.
âYou should go,â she told her quietly. âAnd put the closed sign on the door, please.â
Her friend hesitated, but with a final glance in your direction, she walked out, the soft click of the door behind her leaving the two of you alone. You didnât miss the way sheâd muttered under her breath as she left, a quiet but very clear âBitch.â
âY/n,â Selene said after another moment of silence, her voice tentative, like she was trying to find the right words. âI didnât know that you were here.â
âClearly.â
Seleneâs movements were stiff, awkward as she fidgeted with the hem of her sleeve, like she didnât know what to do with her hands now that she was trapped in this uncomfortable moment. âWhat are you doing here?â
âI donât think that matters anymore,â you replied. âI asked you a question. Iâd like to know what I just overheard.â
Seleneâs ears flushed pink, a deep red that spread across her neck, as she took a deep breath. âI donât know what you want me to say.â
You could feel your patience unraveling. Of course she didnât know what to say. Sheâd been caught in the act. There was no excuse for this.
âYou listened to us,â you snapped, the words bitter in your mouth. âYou spied on Azriel. Do you just want to skip ahead to how you justify it?â
Her face paled, and for a moment, she looked youngerâsmall, almost fragile. âI wasnât trying toââ
âOh please.â The frustration boiled over, flooding your veins with anger you hadnât realized was possible. Anything youâd felt before this moment paled in comparison. You shouldnât have asked her to explain. You already knew whatever she said would only make things worse, would only add fuel to the fire that was your growing irritation.
This is stupid. This is ridiculous. How did you get roped into this?
âI know it was wrong!â she said quickly, the words tumbling out. âI know, okay? I shouldnât haveâI shouldnât have let Runa convince me it was a good idea. But I didnât know what else to do.â
That had to be the worst excuse youâd ever heard. It wasnât just the stupidity of it that pissed you offâit was the weakness of it, the desperation in her voice that made you want to scream. Azriel must be blind. Had he really been so wrapped up in whatever bubble heâd built around her that he couldnât see the cracks? Was he so fucking love-blind that thisâthisâwas what he was left with?
âWhat else to do? About what? Surely any other solution would have been better.â
She let out a deep sigh and her shoulders sagged with the motion. âI really like him, Y/n.â
You snorted, a sound of genuine amusementâmore out of sheer disbelief than anything else. You couldnât help it. âAlright,â you said, dismissing her with a wave of your hand, not buying it for a second. âDonât start.â
âI do,â Selene said, her voice more insistent now. âI think I might even love him. But itâs hard.â
You shot her an unimpressed look.Â
Her voice was louder, more frantic, as she continued. âAzriel doesnât talk about anythingâanything real.â
You didnât bother hiding the scoff. âBullshit. Az talks. You just have to be patient. Communicate like a normal fucking partner.â
Her frustration flashed across her face, the defensive crossing of her arms only making her look more like a child. âDo you think I didnât try that? He doesnât tell me anything. Not really. He keeps everything locked up so tightâhe barely even looks at me sometimes. What was I supposed to do?â
âMaybe not violate his privacy?âÂ
âYou donât get it.â Her hands trembled as she gestured at you. âHe doesnât talk to me like he talks to you. Do you know what itâs like to be the one heâs supposed to care about but feel like youâre always on the outside? Like thereâs this wall between us that I canât get through, but somehow you can?â
You shouldâve walked away then. The urge to just let her talk herself into a hole was strong. But you didnât.
âYouâve been dating him for a few months,â you said, crossing your arms, your stance slightly defensive. âWeâve been friends for centuries. You canât expect him to open up to you completely overnight.â
âThatâs not the point!â she snapped, her voice rising, a crack of desperation leaking through. For a fleeting second, you almost felt bad for her. A tug of sympathy.
âThen what the hell is the point?â you demanded. âBecause from where Iâm standing, it looks like youâre just looking for someone to blame. And for some reason, that someone is me. Are you seriously trying to imply I'm somehow responsible for you spying on him?â
Selene flinched, but she didnât back down. You had to give her credit for that. âNo. IâI donât know,â she mumbled, her hand tugging at her hair in jerky movements, like she was trying to yank the thoughts from her mind. âI panicked, okay? I didnât thinkâI just⊠I didnât want to lose him. I thought if I could figure out what was going on, maybe I could fix it. Maybe I could stop feeling likeâŠâ
âLike what?âÂ
âLike Iâm always on the outside. Like Iâm never going to be enough.â
A part of you wanted to snap back at her, to remind her that this wasnât a justification, that none of this made it okay. But something about her voiceâbroken, raw, like a crack that had been growing for too longâslowed your response. Your anger faltered.
âI know itâs insane,â she added, âI know it was wrong, and I feel awful about it. But I didnât know what else to do. It feels like iâm competing with someone whoâs known him longer, who gets to see parts of him I never will. How am I supposed to make space for myself?â
âStill not a good enough excuse,â you bit out. âYou canât just violate his privacy because youâre insecure.â
Selene took a deep breath and met your gaze. There was no fight in them anymore. âPlease, just go. Run off and tell Azriel everything. I know youâre probably excited to.â
Her words stung more than they should have.
âWhy do you say it like that?â you asked, âLike Iâm thrilled to ruin your relationship?â
Seleneâs eyes flickered with something sharp. âArenât you?â
For a second, you almost wished you could be. Almost.
âNo,â you said firmly. âI would never do that to Azriel. Iâm not your competition. Iâm his friend. I came here to give you the benefit of the doubt because I wanted you two to be happy. But this? This isâŠâ You trailed off, unable to even finish the thought, because it was too muchâeverything about it felt wrong.
âCrazy?â Selene finished bitterly, shaking her head. âYeah, I know. Believe me, I know how it looks. But like I said, you donât get it. You donât know what itâs like to care about someone so much that you start losing sight of yourself. I think about him, about how much I care about him, and all my instincts go out the window. â
Selene had always existed a certain way in your mind.
Azriel had seemed lighter when he first mentioned her, a softness in his voice that you hadnât heard in years. And youâd been happy for himâthrilled, even, at the idea of someone bringing him a bit of joy. Youâd wanted to give her the benefit of the doubt, wanted to believe that she could be good for him. You were excited to meet her.
But then Az started to change.
The more he changed, the more Selene shifted in your mind, too. She became untouchable, an image conjured more from your worry than from anything real. You imagined her as someone clingy, someone who demanded all of his attention and made him forget the people who loved him first. Someone full of herself, reveling in the power she had over him.
And then youâd met her.
She wasnât what youâd expectedâthough not in the way that might have changed your mind. She wasnât warm or open, wasnât eager to charm or connect with Azrielâs family. Instead, sheâd clung to him like a second skin, her hands always on his arm, her smile reserved only for him. And maybe it was unfair, but you hadnât liked the way sheâd looked at you, hadnât liked the guarded, wary edge to her voice when she spoke.
Youâd trusted your gut, let it guide you through the uncertainty. And when things fell apartâwhen the argument between you and Az finally eruptedâSeleneâs image had shifted again.
She became a villain in your mind, a figure painted in sharp, unforgiving lines. It was easier that way. Easier to picture her whispering in Azrielâs ear, twisting his thoughts, pulling him further away from you. Youâd built her into someone cruel, someone who reveled in the divide sheâd caused.
But now, standing before her, you saw something else entirely.
Selene didnât look cruel. She didnât look smug or victorious. If anything, she looked fragile. There was an unease in her posture, a vulnerability in the way her hands fidgeted at her sides. The guardedness was still there, but it felt more like armor than arrogance.
And for the first time, you questioned how much of the image youâd built of her was realâand how much of it was your own fear, your own concern for Azriel, projected onto her.
âWhy did you tell Azriel that I had feelings for him?â
The words slipped out before you could stop them, and you werenât sure where they came fromâbut somehow, they lifted a deep weight off your chest.
Her brows furrowed, genuine confusion crossing her face. "What?"
âWhy did you tell him that you thought I had feelings for him?â
âI wanted to see what heâd do,â she admitted.Â
Disbelief tightened in your chest. âSo you lied to him for fun?â
She shook her head. âNo I didnât.â
âYes,â you said, the word bitten out, âYou told him I had feelings for him.â
âBecause you do,â she answered, as though it were the simplest thing in the world, like she understood your feelings better than you did. And for a secondâa stupid, fleeting secondâyou almost believed her.
Seleneâs gaze didnât waver. âI know what a female in love with him looks like,â she said quietly, her voice soft in a way it wasnât before. âI see it every day when I look in the mirror.â
Something inside you twisted painfully, a knot of emotions you couldnât untangle fast enough. You focused on the irritation.Â
âAm I wrong?â she continued. âIs he the best part of your day? Do you look forward to talking to him? Can you tell him things youâd never tell anyone else? Do you save bits of good food just so he can try it?â
Your throat felt tight, the words stuck somewhere between anger and disbelief. How had this conversation managed to spin so completely?
The breath you took felt jagged, like your lungs couldnât quite expand all the way. âThatâs not true,â you said. âAzriel and I⊠Weâre friends. Thatâs all. Weâve been friends for centuries. Thatâs justâwhat happens when youâve known someone that long.â
For a moment, you thought she might apologize, or at least reconsider. Her expression faltered, but instead, she just stared at you.
âDo you really believe that?â
When you didnât reply, Selene blinked, cleared her throat, and turned away from you, leaning against the counter with a sigh. âThis is so pathetic,â she muttered, her voice tinged with bitter amusement. âIâm standing here, basically pushing you to him.â
A sigh slipped past your lips before you could stop it. You hesitated, torn between frustration and a strange sympathy. Against every instinct telling you to be petty, a part of you felt bad for her. She cared about Azriel. Deeply. You were certain of itâ unsure of how you knew, but you were certain nonetheless. There was no malice in her voice, just insecurity and raw, unspoken fear.
You hated that you could sense it, but you couldn't ignore it either. You could almost hear Amren in your ear, urging you to walk away, and Mor's voice reminding you that Selene didnât deserve your kindness. But somehow, you couldn't bring yourself to leave. If Azriel saw something worth loving in Selene, maybe you did too.
âOkay, well, donât do that,â you muttered, taking a step closer. The urge to comfort her was almost overwhelmingâto show her that maybe she could learn and grow from this. âYou need to talk to Az, Selene. Just sit down, be openââ
âStop. Donât be nice to me,â she snapped, spinning to face you. Her voice was sharp.
She moved as if to push you away, but hadnât realized how close youâd stepped. The edge of her bracelet caught your cheek, and the sharp sting of metal cut straight through it.
Selene froze, her eyes widening as she took in the line of blood blooming on your cheek. âOh my gods,â she whispered, her hands hovering uselessly. âIâI didnât meanââ
You stepped back further, your hand still on your cheek, blood warm against your fingertips.Â
This seemed about right, you thought bitterly to yourself. This is what happens when you try to be the bigger person. You were gonna kill Cassian. You were going to wring his godsdamned neck.
Seleneâs voice became a rush of apologies, each one more frantic than the last, but your attention was already slipping away. Your gaze fell to the bracelet on her wrist. The metal gleamed, twisting slightly with every motion of her hand. You recognized it instantly.
Azriel had a similar one in his room. On his dresser.
âIs that how you did it?â you asked, pointing to her wrist.
Seleneâs face drained of color, guilt flooding her expression. She nodded slowly, her hands shaking as she removed the bracelet and held it out to you, eyes wide and full of regret.
You took it from her fingers and, just for a moment, you almost let yourself fall back into the anger, the hurt. But you didnât. You exhaled slowly, steadying yourself before shaking your head.
âIâm sorry,â Selene whispered, voice breaking. âI really am. I wasâ I was just desperate. And Runa kept pushing, andââ
You cut her off with a sharp shake of your head, locking eyes with her. Her voice faded, but it didnât matter anymore. âYouâre not terrible, Selene. But you have terrible friends.â
You turned to leave but paused at the door, glancing back over your shoulder. âI suggest you find new ones.â
You tried to steady yourself as you stepped into the bustling streets of Velaris. The bracelet in your hand was cold against your palm, and the sting of the cut on your cheek throbbed with each beat of your pulse. Everything inside you felt scrambledâemotions tangled, confusion still clouding your mind.
The shuffle of footsteps broke through your fog. You looked up, just in time to hear a sharp voice.
âOuch, that looks like it stung.â A small chuckle. âAlthough Iâm sure youâre excited to have a reason for the Shadowsinger to tend to you.â
You scanned her. âRuna, right?â
She smirked, crossing her arms. âYeah, that's me.â
Without hesitation, you found yourself saying, âYou gave your friend some hurtful advice.â
Runa shrugged nonchalantly, almost amused. âOops.â
You held your tongue for a moment, your irritation intensifying the longer you looked at her. Unlike Selene, who had managed to evoke some sympathy, Runa didnât even come close. She shifted, as if waiting for you to bite.
The silence stretched before she finally broke it with a snide laugh. âHonestly, Seleneâs better off without that freak of a boyfriend. She doesnât need to be wrapped up with shitty court politicians.â
Something in you snapped. Maybe it was the words, maybe it was the whirlwind of emotions from the last half hour, but your patience with her was gone. You inhaled sharply, trying to steady your temper, and placed the bracelet in your pocket.
âDo you know who I am?â
Runa raised an eyebrow, the slightest trace of mockery in her smile. âUh, yeah. You're an emissary or something, right?â She waved her hand dismissively, as if it didnât matter.
You closed the distance between you in a few long strides. âGood,â you said, letting the word settle in the air. âI want you to remember that when you report.â
Runa looked confused, her smug attitude faltering. âReport what?âÂ
You smiled. And then you punched her in the face.Â
âč â¶ đ§· â¶âčÂ
authors note: fun fact, this was the 6th draft of this!! and this felt like the way to go with the story....gives me some options to exploree. its also so long bc i wanted to keep all the fun scenes together tehehe sorry yall i got carried away
but selene....selene...selene... how i thought about her for a bit. i wanted to avoid making selene a caricature of a soulless mean jealous girl, i think it makes it somehow worse and even better to write knowing she was just incredibly insecure and misguided by people she trusted...doesnât make anythinggg she did okay but
we out here rly testing our reader with a selene like villain rn. tehehe
also....time to imagine rhys holding nyx on his lap as he tells reader that shes in trouble for fighting a citizen in the open mf streets. rhys was so smug and now heâs like damnâŠwait a min⊠our public imagine SUCKSS
thank you for reading!!<3
permanent tag list đ«¶đ»:Â
@rhysandorian @itsswritten @lilah-asteria @georgiadixon @glam-targaryenÂ
@cheneyq @darkbloodsly @pit-and-the-pen @azrielsbbg @evergreenlarkÂ
@marina468 @azriels-human @book-obsessed124 @bubybubsters @starswholistenanddreamsansweredÂ
@feyretopia @ninthcircleofprythian @azrielrot @justyouraveragekleemain @marigold-morelliÂ
@mrsjna @anarchiii @alittlelostalittlefound @melissat1254 @secretsicanthideanymore
@m4tthewmurd0ck @beardburnsupersoldiers @isnotwhatyourethinking @tothestarsandwhateverend @raginghellfire
@angel-graces-world-of-chaos @acoazlove @paradisebabey @inkedinshadows @mellowmusings
@paankhaleyaaar @curiosandcourioser @thisrandombitch @casiiopea2 @w0nderw0manly
@rottenroyalebooks @jurdanpotter @casiiopea2












