Popular (reader) x semi popular (ellie William)
Synopsis: she comes over everything was nice at first but your thoughts crept in Ellie tried to help but it didnât work you ended up going through weeks of self hate but then something broke in you and now youâre at Ellieâs house
Content: homophobia, mental issues, fluff, internalized homophobia, arguing, angst, friends to lovers, a lot of gay stuff, modern au, nicknames, sad, dual pov, trash parents.
A/N: (THIS IS DISCONTINUED) Iâm so tired I worked hard to feed my babies hope yall en joyed I may have messed up on some parts donât mind it.
Taglist: @kamogrrl @liasxeatt @theeprettiestlittleliar @ellz47 @vahnilla
Soon you wake up from your beautiful nap
The rest of the house was quite except for the rain hitting the glass window and the humming of the heater and your parents usual muffled conversation. Good thing your cramps calmed down enough you were able to sit up
Your phone was face down beside you, the last unread text from Ellie glowing faintly underneath. Youâd read it a dozen times already.
Ellie: You sure youâre okay? I could stop by after work.
You never replied. Because the thought of her actually showing up made your chest ache. You didnât know what would hurt more seeing her, or pretending you didnât want to.
You froze your stomach turning your body felt who it was before you even saw her. The night outside was dark, rain misting against the glass and there she was. Ellie. Hood up, cheeks pink from the cold, a little grin pulling at her lips as she held up a plastic bag like it was a peace offering.
You drew your curtains back a little confused by the bag âif itâs food then youâre able to come inside.â You mouthed back Ellie rolled her eyes showing you that it had food in it
You rolled your eyes, but your heart was racing. You lifted the window, letting a cold breeze rush in as Ellie climbed inside like sheâd done it a hundred times before. She landed softly, brushing rain off her jacket.
âHey,â she said, voice low. âMiss me?â
You crossed your arms, trying to sound annoyed and not completely flustered. âYou canât just sneak into peopleâs rooms.â
âTechnically,â she said, setting the bag on your desk, âI knocked.â
You blinked at the bag. âSo what goodies did you bring me.â
âA Care package.â She started unpacking it a heating pad, chocolate, Advil, and a small container of soup. âMy grandmaâs recipe. Works miracles. Figured you werenât exactly having the best day.â
You hated how badly you wanted to kiss her from just doing a nice gesture âthanks.â You mumbled
Ellie just smiled and sat on the floor, leaning her back against the wall like she belonged there. âYou really werenât gonna answer my texts, huh?â
You hesitated. âDidnât know what to say.â
âThat you were dying of cramps?â she teased.
You smirked, but it didnât reach your eyes. âDidnât wanna bother you.â
Ellie looked up at you then really looked. âYou never bother me.â
You stared back words not being able to form the air in the room felt heavy thick but soft at the same time.
âEllie-â you scrambled for tissues, but she was already laughing, holding a hand under her nose.
âGuess your windowâs cursed,â she said, voice muffled. âEvery time Iâm near it, my nose decides to explode.â
You couldnât help but laugh an actual laugh as you handed her tissues. âYouâre such an idiot.â
âI prefer âheroic visitor bearing soup,â but okay.â
The moment stretched between you. She wiped her nose, smirking, but her eyes were softer now. âYou look better when you laugh.â
That one sentence made your stomach twist in ways that had nothing to do with cramps.
You turned away, suddenly too aware of the space between you and how badly you wanted to close it. âDonât say stuff like that.â
âBecause.â You swallowed. âYou know why.â
Ellie didnât move, didnât flinch. âNo, I donât. Maybe you should tell me.â
You shook your head, pacing to your desk. âYou donât get it, Ellie. My mom already thinks people like you are⌠wrong.â
Ellieâs voice went quieter. âPeople like me?â
You bit your lip, hating yourself even as you said it. âYou know what I mean.â
âDo I?â she said, standing now. âBecause last time I checked, youâre not exactly straight either.â
That hit you like a punch. âWHAT!-â
âItâs okay,â she said quickly. âIâm not mad. I just-â she rubbed her arm, searching for words. âYou keep acting like this thing between us is some big mistake, but itâs not. Itâs real.â
You wanted to scream that she was wrong, that she didnât understand, that you couldnât be what she thought you were. But all that came out was a whisper.
âMy mom would be disgusted by me she may even disown me.â
Ellie stepped closer, slow, cautious. âThen she doesnât deserve to know this part of you. she doesnât love you unconditionally.â
Her voice was soft now, almost breaking. âyou donât have to hate yourself just because she taught you to. Nothing is wrong with you.â
That was it the dam broke. You sank onto the edge of your bed, crying quietly into your hands. Ellie didnât say anything, just knelt beside you, one hand resting lightly on your arm.
For a while, all you could hear was the rain against the window and the sound of your own heartbeat.
Finally, you looked up, voice trembling. âWhy are you being so nice to me?â
Ellie smiled tired, gentle. âBecause Iâve been where you are.â
You blinked, tears still slipping down your cheeks. âAnd what happened?â
âI found someone who told me it was okay to stop hiding.â
You didnât say anything after that. You just leaned into her, and she wrapped her arms around you, warm and solid. For a moment, the world outside your window didnât exist just rain, and breathing, and the quiet relief of being held.
When she finally pulled away, she grinned softly. âYou should probably get some sleep. Soupâs on your desk.â
You nodded, eyes red. âThanks⌠for everything.â
Ellie climbed back out the window. You didnât want her to leave she took the warmth and your joy with her only leaving pain behind
You sat there staring at the window long after she was gone, one hand over your heart, whispering to yourself half prayer, half promise:
âI wish I could believe that.â
Ellie woke up to the smell of burnt coffee and the sound of Joel coughing in the other room.
She groaned, rolling onto her side and smacking the alarm on her nightstand until it shut up. Her phone buzzed beside her another message from her boss reminding her about the afternoon shift at the library cafĂŠ. She ignored it for a second, eyes still half closed, brain still halfway stuck on last night.
She laid there for a second, staring at the ceiling, trying to replay every second of that night your eyes when you cried, the way you leaned into her like you were scared youâd fall apart if she didnât. Ellie hadnât meant to make her cry, but she wasnât gonna lie seeing her let it out felt⌠real. Like you finally stopped pretending for five fucking minutes.
Then Ellieâs alarm went off again at 6:30, and Ellie groaned into her pillow, hitting the snooze button like it was her worst enemy. Her room still smelled faintly like the rain from last night soaked hoodie draped over her chair, guitar propped against the wall, open sketchbook full of half-finished doodles and lyrics.
She dragged herself out of bed, hair a mess, and padded into the kitchen. Joel was already there, coughing into a napkin, trying to pretend it didnât hurt.
âYou shouldâve stayed in bed, old man,â she muttered, opening the fridge.
Joel grunted. âCanât stay in bed when youâre the one payinâ bills now.â
Ellie rolled her eyes but smiled anyway. âIâm just workinâ part-time.â
He smirked, but his voice came out rough. âStill. Proud of you, kiddo.â
And that hit her in the chest. Because it didnât matter how old she got hearing Joel say that still made her feel like she was doing something right.
She poured him some orange juice, sliding it across the table. âYou gonna take it easy today?â
He shrugged. âGot a doctorâs appointment later. Donât worry about me.â
âI can drive you being late to school never bothers me.â Ellie said a little more firm
Joel sighs âitâs fine I should be able to drive myself like I said donât worry about me.â
Ellie sighed giving up âyeah, fine.â
Soon you were at school which wasnât quiet it never was.
People always had something to say when it came to Ellie Williams. She didnât even try to be popular; it just happened. The easy smile, the guitar at lunch, the way she could joke with anyone and make it feel natural. Everyone wanted a piece of her, but no one really knew her.
She could still feel the weight of your head on her shoulder from last night, the tremble in your voice when you said your mom would hate you. The way you tried so hard to hide the softness in your eyes like you were scared it would give you away.
She thought about that a lot, actually.
You werenât like everyone else. You didnât just look at her you saw her.
And that scared the hell out of her.
âYo, Ellie!â one of her friends Marcus, loud and always too hyped called across the courtyard. âHeard youâre doing another open mic this Friday. That true?â
Ellie shrugged, slinging her backpack higher. âMaybe. Depends.â
âWhether I feel like being the entertainment for you clowns again.â
He laughed, clapping her on the shoulder. âYou love it, donât lie.â
The music. The crowd. The way everyone cheered when she played something new. It was the only time she didnât feel like she was holding her breath.
during lunch, when everyone gathered around her table, laughing and talking, Ellie smiled like she always did but her heart wasnât in it.
Because all she could think about was how bad she wanted to text you again.
Something that wouldnât sound like I miss you but still kind of meant it.
She just stared at her phone, thumb hovering over your name, before locking the screen and shoving it back in her pocket.
âEllie, you good?â Marcus asked, raising a brow.
âYeah,â she said automatically, forcing a smirk. âJust thinking.â
He grinned. âAbout that girl from chem who keeps staring at you?â
Ellie snorted. âNah. Sheâs not my type.â
He leaned forward. âThen what is your type?â
Her smirk faded a little. âComplicated.â
By the time the final bell rang, Ellie was exhausted not from the classes, but from pretending she was fine. She stopped by her locker, tossing books inside and pulling out her guitar case.
Joel: Doctor says itâs just a bad infection. Iâll be home late, kiddo. Donât worry.
She smiled softly. Donât worry. He always said that, even when things were bad.
Which kinda reminded her of you and how you always said you were fine ok even when you werenât Ellie chuckled to herself âalways clinging to the sick.â She whispered under her breath
She slung her guitar over her shoulder and started walking toward the parking lot. The air smelled like rain again, and her fingers itched for her phone.
Maybe you were home. Maybe you were still in bed. Maybe you were thinking about her too.
But Ellie didnât text you. Not yet.
Because she knew you were fighting something bigger than her something that didnât just disappear after one night. And as much as it hurt, sheâd wait.
Wait for you to stop flinching when she said your name.
Wait for you to believe that loving her wasnât wrong.
Wait for you to finally look at her without guilt shadowing your eyes.
Until then, sheâd just keep showing up.
In songs youâd never admit were about her.
Because if there was one thing Ellie Williams knew how to do it was hold on to people she cared about, even when they tried to run.
You stopped checking your phone.
Not because you didnât want to you did. Every hour, your brain screamed at you to look, to see if Ellie had texted, to find some proof that last night hadnât just been a fever dream. But you couldnât. You were scared that if you saw her name, everything inside you would cave again.
So you ignored it. You ignored her.
School became background noise. Teachers talked, friends waved, Dina tried to corner you in the hallway once, but you slipped away before she could say a word. You didnât want to hear apologies. You didnât want to talk about Jesse. You didnât want to talk about Ellie.
You just wanted to disappear.
your momâs voice echoing in your head:
Itâs not normal. Itâs not normal. Itâs not normal.
You could still hear her tone, sharp and disappointed, the same way she sounded when you got a bad grade or forgot to smile at church.
But this time, it wasnât something you could fix.
You couldnât just study harder to stop loving a girl. Although you wished you could it would make a lot of things easier.
At home, things got worse.
Your parents had stopped pretending. The arguments werenât whispers behind closed doors anymore they were full-blown storms that shook the walls. Youâd wake up to shouting downstairs, or plates slamming into counters.
Your dad was gone most nights, saying he was âstaying with a friend.â Your mom started pacing more, drinking more coffee, snapping at small things.
The house didnât feel like home anymore.
It felt like a waiting room before something exploded.
And you were the ghost floating between them.
Too quiet to be noticed, too tired to care.
Alex noticed, though. He always did.
Heâd knock on your door sometimes, asking if you wanted to play cards or watch something. Youâd smile, tell him you were busy, and watch his little face fall every single time.
You hated yourself for it.
But you couldnât do anything else.
You couldnât be a big sister when you were barely holding yourself together.
Although you missed the time you and Alex use to spend together laughing playing now it feels like both of yâall are to tired to even try and communicate
You were in your room, staring at the wall, feeling that strange tightness in your chest that made it hard to breathe. It wasnât crying wouldâve helped. This was worse. This was being so full of emotion that you felt empty.
You hadnât eaten much that day. Barely slept. The mirror scared your pale skin, tired eyes, fake smile. You looked like someone you didnât know.
And through it all, one thought kept eating at you:
You ruined your relationship.
You ruined your friendship.
And worst of all you were ruining yourself for something you werenât even allowed to want.
When your phone buzzed again that night, you stared at it for a long time.
Ellie: Hey. Just checking in again. Youâve been quiet. Iâll stop bothering you if you want, just⌠make sure youâre okay, alright?
You couldnât breathe for a second.
You wanted to tell her you missed her, that you werenât okay, that every time you closed your eyes you saw her face and it made you feel both safe and terrified.
But your fingers just hovered over the keyboard, shaking.
Then put your phone face-down again, like it was burning you.
Because she made you feel something real. And real things hurt.
And yet, every night, youâd still look at your window half-expecting to see her there again, hoodie on, grin soft, holding another dumb bag of soup.
Not because she didnât care.
Because maybe she finally believed you didnât want her to.
You told yourself that was good. That it was safer this way.
But when you closed your eyes, the silence was unbearable.
You picked up your phone not even fully thinking.
Ellie laid in bed doom scrolling so she doesnât think of you only to see a message slide down
You: Can you give me your address I need to be anywhere other than here
Ellie: Sure, wait is everything ok
Ellie typed her address out not knowing if this was the best option especially if your mom found out you were at her place
A couple of minutes past you hear a car coming good thing Joel was still at the hospital so he couldnât question why a girl was coming over this late
A soft knock at the door caught Ellie attention she opened the door slightly resting on the doorframe
Hair messy. Hoodie zipped up wrong. Eyes red not from crying, but from being tired. The kind of tired that came from fighting your own brain too long.
Ellie didnât even hesitate inviting you in leading you by your arm to her bedroom once yâall were both inside she closed the door she whispered. âWhat are you doing here?â
You didnât answer right away. You just stood there, breathing like youâd been running, your arms wrapped around yourself.
âI-I didnât know where else to go,â you said finally, voice cracking halfway through.
Ellieâs stomach dropped. âDid something happen? Are you okay?â
You shook your head, and it wasnât really a no more like a please donât make me explain.
ââŚ..what do you want to eat..and make sure your location is off.â Ellie can see you realize that you in fact didnât turn off your location âI donât mind I could eat anything right now.â
Ellie starred at you for a second not sure if you were just saying that âok well my choice thenâ
A couple minutes past and Ellie was back with two bowls of ramen she saw you laying on her bed kinda awkwardly âhereâs your food princess.â Ellie sat next to you, leaving a small gap between you two. Her room smelled faintly like coffee and lemon detergent the same as it always did.
You smiled faintly, eyes dropping to the food. The silence stretched again, and Ellie could feel the weight hanging in the air between you everything unsaid, everything avoided.
Later yâall finished eating setting the bowl on Ellieâs desk. Finally, you whispered, âI donât know whatâs wrong with me.â
Ellie looked at you sharply. âHey, donât say that.â
âIâm serious,â you said, voice trembling. âI keep trying to be normal, but I canât stop thinking about you. And itâs-itâs so stupid. Because I shouldnât. I shouldnât want you.â
You kept going, words spilling faster now like if you didnât let them out, theyâd choke you.
âMy mom keeps saying things about people
like us. And I keep thinking sheâs right. I donât even know who I am anymore, Ellie. I just⌠I hate it. I hate this part of me.â
Ellieâs chest ached. She wanted to punch something. Hug you. Scream. All of it.
She reached out, finally slow, careful and took your hand. You didnât pull away.
âListen,â she said quietly, âyou donât have to figure everything out right now, okay?â
Your eyes lifted to hers glassy, vulnerable, searching.
Ellie squeezed your hand gently. âYouâre not broken. Youâre just scared. And itâs okay to be scared.â
You blinked hard, and a tear slipped down your cheek. You tried to wipe it away fast, embarrassed, but Ellie caught your wrist before you could.
âHey,â she whispered. âYou donât have to hide it.â
For the first time all night, you leaned into her. Slowly. Hesitant. Like a deer testing its steps.
Ellie wrapped her arm around you, pulling you against her chest.
And there it was again that quiet peace that only existed when you were near.
Neither of you said anything for a long time. The house stayed silent. Your breathing evened out.
Ellie didnât know what this was, or what it would become, but she knew one thing for sure she wasnât gonna let you walk home alone tonight.
You were safe here. Even if just for a few hours.
She glanced down at you already half-asleep against her shoulder, your hoodie sleeves bunched up to your chin and whispered softly, like a secret just for the dark:
âYouâll be okay. I promise.â
You fell asleep pressed against her chest, your breathing soft and uneven at first, then slowing until it matched hers. Ellie hadnât even meant to fall asleep too she was just gonna make sure you were okay, that you didnât wake up in the middle of another panic spiral but somewhere between watching the rise and fall of your shoulders and counting the freckles on your cheek, her eyes finally gave in.
The light crept in slow, warm, golden the kind that made everything look softer than it really was. It spilled across her floor, climbed the wall, and finally stretched across her bed until it touched your face.
You scrunched your nose, muttering something incoherent, then shifted closer your hand sliding instinctively around her hoodie like you were afraid sheâd disappear if you let go.
Ellie froze for a second. Not because she didnât like it, but because she did. Too much.
Your head fit perfectly in the space between her neck and shoulder. Your hair tickled her collarbone. She could feel your heartbeat steady, calm against her ribs.
âDamn,â she whispered under her breath, voice low so she wouldnât wake you.
She shouldâve moved. Shouldâve gotten up, opened the curtains wider, anything to keep herself from staring. But she didnât. Instead, she rested her chin lightly on top of your head and just⌠stayed there.
The world outside was already awake birds, cars, someone mowing their lawn too early but in here, it was quiet. The kind of quiet that felt safe.
Then you shifted again, slowly waking up. Your eyelashes fluttered open, and for a second, you just looked at her sleepy, confused, then realizing where you were.
âOh my God,â you murmured, instantly sitting up a bit, face turning red.
Ellie laughed softly. âRelax. You didnât, like, drool on me or anything.â
You glared half-heartedly, pulling your sleeves over your hands. âStill embarrassing.â
âNah.â Ellie stretched, rubbing her eyes. âCouldâve been worse. You couldâve kicked me in your sleep.â
You rolled your eyes but smiled that tiny, tired smile that made Ellieâs chest ache in the best way.
The sun caught your skin just right, lighting up your face, your hair everything. You looked like something she wasnât supposed to touch.
âStop staring,â you said, voice barely above a whisper.
Ellie smirked. âYou wish I would.â
You tried to look away, but your face stayed pink, and Ellie swore she could hear your heartbeat in the quiet.
âHey,â she said softly, serious now. âYou good?â
You hesitated. Then nodded. âYeah⌠I think so.â
And for the first time in weeks, you actually meant it.
The morning light hit the both of you then soft and golden and kind and Ellie thought maybe, just maybe, things didnât have to stay as dark as theyâd been.
She leaned back on the pillow, smiling faintly. âTold you youâd be okay.â
You looked at her really looked and whispered, âYeah⌠maybe I will be.â
The moment hung there, warm and quiet. Two kids, one messy morning, and the sun spilling in like it was rooting for them.
It was quiet again the kind of quiet that felt too soft, too unreal. Morning light still spilled through Ellieâs window, turning the dust in the air into gold. You could hear her breathing next to you, slow, steady. Like she wasnât afraid of anything.
You kept telling yourself to get up, to go home before anyone noticed, before the world came crashing back in. But then she looked at you really looked and every excuse in your head just melted.
Her hair was messy, her voice still rough from sleep when she said, âYouâre thinking too loud again.â
You laughed, nervous. âCanât help it.â
âYeah, you can,â she murmured, scooting a little closer. âJust⌠stop.â
Easy for her to say. Your brain was screaming. You canât do this. You shouldnât want this. What would your mom say? But your heart wasnât listening.
Ellieâs hand brushed against yours, slow, hesitant like she was asking without words.
And somehow, you found the courage to answer.
You turned to face her. Her green eyes caught the sunlight, and for a second, you forgot how to breathe. She looked at you the same way she played her guitar soft but deliberate, like she knew exactly what she was doing.
Then she leaned in, just enough for you to feel her breath on your lips. You didnât think you just moved.
The kiss was small, barely there, but it hit like a spark in your chest. Warm, gentle, terrifying. You could taste mint and something sweet, maybe coffee from earlier, maybe her.
When you finally pulled back, your hands were shaking. So were hers.
Neither of you said anything at first. Just⌠breathed.
Then Ellie smiled, that lazy, crooked grin that made you want to hide and laugh at the same time. âTook you long enough,â she whispered.
You rolled your eyes, but you couldnât stop smiling either. âShut up.â
She laughed quietly, brushing her thumb against your cheek. âYouâre cute when youâre flustered.â
âEllieââ you started, but your voice gave out halfway through her name.
âYeah?â she asked, still grinning.
âNothing,â you whispered, shaking your head, the smile slipping back onto your lips.
Because you didnât have words for how it felt the sunlight, the softness, the ache in your chest that wasnât fear this time.
And for the first time in forever, you didnât want to run from it.