I mean this in the nicest way possible and because I would like to have context. How can you justify aging up characters?
I just want to get your thoughts on this because for me, they are kids.
Also, if you are okay with aging up characters, are you okay with the fact that more likely than not there are minors who are going to be reading your work and thinking it’s okay to interact with adult content because the characters are only 14/15 years old?
You all use the argument that they “age faster” but they are still children. Lo’ak (and Neteyam too) don’t even look they have gone through puberty.
Again, I am not trying to fight. This fandom will forever be divided on this. I personally just don’t get the justification and would like to have a conversation about this.
Hey, I really appreciate you reaching out and wanting to have a respectful conversation about this. I get that this is a pretty sensitive and often divisive topic within the fandom, so l'll do my best to explain my perspective.
First off, it’s really important to remember that these characters are entirely fictional, they don’t exist in real life. Aging them up doesn’t mean being attracted to real children or teenagers, it’s about imagining these characters in a different context. Fiction and reality are separate things, and just because I choose to age up a character doesn’t mean I’m okay with or support anything inappropriate involving actual minors!
One of the main reasons I age up these characters is because, in canon, they still act a lot like kids, and that doesn’t really fit the kind of stories I want to tell. I like imagining them as adults because I can see how they would behave when they’re more mature, and that version of them is attractive to me. It’s not about being drawn to their younger selves at all.
Also, if it were just about making them barely legal to avoid criticism, I would age them up to around 18. But that’s not what I do. I usually make them at least 25-28 years old because that’s closer to my own age, and I’m attracted to people around my age group. I don’t want them to be just technically adults, i want to Imagine them as fully grown, mature individuals who fit the context of the stories I want to create.
To be honest, I do think these characters are all pretty looking, and that’s obviously a big reason why I want to write for them and imagine them as adults. It’s natural to find certain characters aesthetically appealing or interesting, and for me, aging them up makes sense because I want to picture them in a way that aligns with my own age and preferences.
When I first watched the movie, by the looks of them all I actually thought they were around 18 or 19 years old. They’re literally fighting in a war alongside their parents, and they’re portrayed as capable and skilled in battle, which gave off a more adult vibe. When I got home and looked up their ages, I was really surprised to find out they were younger. So when I create content, I’m imagining them as older, more mature versions of themselves, because that’s how they seemed to me at first, and it makes more sense for the stories I want to explore.
Another thing to keep in mind is that I don’t just say they’re aged up and leave the rest of their story as it is in the movies. I usually change a lot about their lives and their situations to make it even more obvious that they’re grown up. I reimagine their personalities, experiences, and relationships to reflect a more mature, adult version of them. I don’t just up their age number, i want to fully develop them as older, more mature individuals.
I understand that some people might still be uncomfortable with aging up characters, and that’s totally valid. But it’s important to recognize that aging up a fictional character is fundamentally different from being attracted to real-life minors. It’s about creativity and storytelling within the context of fiction, not real-life situations.
Again, I want to make it clear that aging up has nothing to do with being attracted to kids/teens. For me, it’s about reimagining these characters as adults so I can explore more mature themes in my work without feeling uncomfortable. In fanfiction and fandom spaces, aging up characters is a pretty common practice because it allows writers and creators to explore different scenarios, especially when canon doesn’t give us much to work with. It’s a way to take characters we love and think about how they might grow up, change, or navigate adult situations.
Also, another big reason why people age up characters is because they feel attached to the personalities, dynamics, or potential that these characters have, not because of their age in canon. It’s also important to remember that fictional characters aren’t real people, they don’t have actual lives, feelings, or experiences. When we age them up, we’re essentially creating alternate versions that are separate from their younger selves. It’s more about imagination and creativity than anything else.
Regarding the concern about minors consuming this content, I totally understand why that might worry some people. The reality of being on the internet is that it’s impossible to fully control who views what, but I do my best to act responsibly. I clearly label my content, include warnings, and state explicitly that it’s for adults only. If I find out that someone interacting with my work is a minor, I block them immediately. Ultimately, I can only control my own space and my own behavior. I take my responsibility as a creator seriously, but I’m not responsible for what others, especially minors, choose to engage with online.
At the end of the day, I know not everyone will agree with aging up characters, and that’s okay. Fandom spaces are diverse, and it’s normal for people to have different boundaries and comfort levels. I just hope this explanation helps you understand where I’m coming from. I’m always open to discussing things respectfully, and I really do appreciate you taking the time to ask rather than assuming the worst. 🩵